Luận án Phân tích đầu tư chứng khoán trên thị trường chứng khoán Việt Nam bằng phương pháp thống kê phân vị
Khi xét nhóm cổ phiếu thuộc ba ngành Tài chính, Ngân hàng và Bảo hiểm,
nhóm Bất động sản, Xây dựng, nhóm Hàng tiêu dùng thiết yếu, luận án mở rộng mô
hình CAPM bằng cách đưa thêm 2 nhân tố quy mô vốn và giá trị sổ sách vào mô
hình – đây chính là mô hình Fama-French. Kết quả cho thấy rằng khi thị trường ổn
định cũng như biến động, lợi suất cổ phiếu không phụ thuộc vào quy mô vốn cũng
như giá trị công ty. Cuối cùng, nghiên cứu bổ sung nhân tố ngành vào mô hình FamaFrench, kết quả cho thấy rằng trong trường hợp thị trường ổn định cũng như bất ổn,
lợi suất cổ phiếu phụ thuộc vào lợi suất thị trường cũng như yếu tố ngành. Mức độ
phụ thuộc vào nhân tố thị trường và nhân tố ngành nhiều hay ít còn do đặc thù của
ngành quyết định.
195 trang |
Chia sẻ: builinh123 | Lượt xem: 1004 | Lượt tải: 3
Bạn đang xem trước 20 trang tài liệu Luận án Phân tích đầu tư chứng khoán trên thị trường chứng khoán Việt Nam bằng phương pháp thống kê phân vị, để xem tài liệu hoàn chỉnh bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
6061 0.059489 19.93753 0
0.8 1.252236 0.069888 17.91779 0
0.9 1.222384 0.07887 15.49878 0
0.95 1.050887 0.134527 7.811703 0
0.99 0.808039 0.573525 1.408901 0.1591
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: PVD C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.018388 0.00222 -8.283144 0
0.1 -0.013095 0.002163 -6.05541 0
0.2 -0.008408 0.001602 -5.248772 0
0.3 -0.004424 0.001607 -2.752697 0.006
0.4 -0.0017 0.001724 -0.986445 0.3241
0.5 0.002066 0.001701 1.214947 0.2246
0.6 0.006267 0.001877 3.338305 0.0009
0.7 0.013571 0.001846 7.35034 0
0.8 0.01889 0.002296 8.228133 0
152
0.9 0.028185 0.002801 10.06258 0
0.95 0.040903 0.003716 11.00777 0
0.99 0.053126 0.007961 6.672958 0
VNINDEX 0.05 1.278543 0.063928 19.99969 0
0.1 1.267442 0.069396 18.26388 0
0.2 1.1759 0.051321 22.91271 0
0.3 1.151712 0.051568 22.33379 0
0.4 1.105312 0.053611 20.61733 0
0.5 1.102394 0.049666 22.19599 0
0.6 1.122386 0.052937 21.20228 0
0.7 1.197639 0.050067 23.92079 0
0.8 1.19097 0.06891 17.28296 0
0.9 1.205092 0.075326 15.99825 0
0.95 1.342889 0.090172 14.89261 0
0.99 1.078602 0.263866 4.087692 0
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: STB C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.037992 0.003143 -12.08728 0
0.1 -0.02767 0.001852 -14.94293 0
0.2 -0.022043 0.001714 -12.85829 0
0.3 -0.017463 0.001867 -9.35183 0
0.4 -0.015344 0.001679 -9.14111 0
0.5 -0.013779 0.001795 -7.676971 0
0.6 -0.00886 0.002175 -4.074445 0
0.7 -0.00502 0.002432 -2.064121 0.0392
0.8 0.003023 0.002635 1.147103 0.2516
0.9 0.01936 0.002704 7.158488 0
0.95 0.024759 0.003019 8.201075 0
0.99 0.026139 0.003581 7.300268 0
153
VNINDEX 0.05 0.706546 0.089493 7.894954 0
0.1 0.773764 0.052207 14.82106 0
0.2 0.722464 0.052202 13.83983 0
0.3 0.697456 0.062796 11.10675 0
0.4 0.652652 0.053902 12.10807 0
0.5 0.605667 0.056313 10.75533 0
0.6 0.646735 0.065646 9.851829 0
0.7 0.638431 0.072649 8.787895 0
0.8 0.704477 0.069388 10.15275 0
0.9 0.832742 0.078231 10.64468 0
0.95 0.671247 0.118858 5.647484 0
0.99 0.26639 0.120025 2.219459 0.0266
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: VCB C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.011333 0.001736 -6.529333 0
0.1 -0.009785 0.001468 -6.665987 0
0.2 -0.002908 0.001622 -1.792973 0.0732
0.3 -0.001489 0.00143 -1.041381 0.2979
0.4 0.001004 0.001485 0.676333 0.499
0.5 0.003486 0.001456 2.393449 0.0168
0.6 0.008224 0.001603 5.130313 0
0.7 0.011992 0.001614 7.430521 0
0.8 0.017909 0.001836 9.75409 0
0.9 0.030282 0.003813 7.94272 0
0.95 0.036765 0.0023 15.9864 0
0.99 0.037223 0.003509 10.60669 0
VNINDEX 0.05 1.33096 0.0639 20.82884 0
0.1 1.243975 0.046739 26.61524 0
0.2 1.252285 0.052335 23.92828 0
154
0.3 1.180975 0.045883 25.73887 0
0.4 1.151725 0.046161 24.94995 0
0.5 1.141784 0.043652 26.15667 0
0.6 1.190274 0.046038 25.85429 0
0.7 1.206702 0.045629 26.44582 0
0.8 1.239289 0.051056 24.27311 0
0.9 1.343473 0.108098 12.42834 0
0.95 1.261689 0.076467 16.4998 0
0.99 0.708596 0.173292 4.08902 0
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: VNM C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.022974 0.001004 -22.87569 0
0.1 -0.021522 0.001347 -15.9792 0
0.2 -0.019609 0.001309 -14.97673 0
0.3 -0.017477 0.001413 -12.36712 0
0.4 -0.014876 0.001273 -11.68597 0
0.5 -0.013423 0.001287 -10.43141 0
0.6 -0.011412 0.001301 -8.773556 0
0.7 -0.008441 0.001468 -5.749488 0
0.8 -0.001883 0.001925 -0.977996 0.3283
0.9 0.013698 0.002416 5.669119 0
0.95 0.022029 0.002908 7.575889 0
0.99 0.030042 0.006294 4.772995 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.836165 0.029247 28.59004 0
0.1 0.720133 0.051394 14.01207 0
0.2 0.621644 0.04208 14.77305 0
0.3 0.594189 0.044442 13.37001 0
0.4 0.596172 0.040064 14.88052 0
0.5 0.571192 0.039805 14.34958 0
155
0.6 0.565326 0.039953 14.14994 0
0.7 0.583576 0.04222 13.82221 0
0.8 0.658969 0.0482 13.67146 0
0.9 0.896593 0.051016 17.57458 0
0.95 0.956083 0.079939 11.96019 0
0.99 0.740723 0.263247 2.813794 0.005
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: AAM C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.061044 0.005199 -11.74183 0
0.1 -0.042376 0.004091 -10.35705 0
0.2 -0.032124 0.002207 -14.55527 0
0.3 -0.029325 0.001253 -23.39635 0
0.4 -0.029172 0.000877 -33.27395 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.000946 -33.2992 0
0.6 -0.031504 0.000917 -34.37173 0
0.7 -0.020284 0.001968 -10.30551 0
0.8 -0.005771 0.002994 -1.927637 0.0541
0.9 0.007232 0.003648 1.982783 0.0476
0.95 0.020618 0.005934 3.474555 0.0005
0.99 0.030167 0.007178 4.202885 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.460125 0.117379 3.920008 0.0001
0.1 0.526629 0.110833 4.75155 0
0.2 0.364283 0.084673 4.302256 0
0.3 0.24754 0.049968 4.953969 0
0.4 0.109051 0.027872 3.912533 0.0001
0.5 1.39E-17 0.029714 4.67E-16 1
0.6 0 0.028869 0 1
0.7 0.208288 0.047666 4.369729 0
0.8 0.423524 0.061223 6.917752 0
156
0.9 0.416726 0.107967 3.859762 0.0001
0.95 0.452657 0.224391 2.017265 0.0439
0.99 0.022058 0.199842 0.110376 0.9121
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: ACC C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.071979 0.006784 -10.60935 0
0.1 -0.045754 0.005378 -8.507473 0
0.2 -0.028257 0.002094 -13.49523 0
0.3 -0.028281 0.001342 -21.07897 0
0.4 -0.031504 0.000894 -35.24015 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.000932 -33.81978 0
0.6 -0.027944 0.000952 -29.36573 0
0.7 -0.015844 0.002358 -6.718291 0
0.8 0.000733 0.002828 0.259225 0.7955
0.9 0.015274 0.004009 3.810079 0.0001
0.95 0.019331 0.002225 8.686391 0
0.99 0.02456 0.004476 5.487651 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.23096 0.182496 1.265559 0.2059
0.1 0.626807 0.105043 5.967118 0
0.2 0.541059 0.092392 5.856133 0
0.3 0.215464 0.052501 4.10398 0
0.4 5.55E-17 0.026748 2.08E-15 1
0.5 0 0.027877 0 1
0.6 0.085366 0.028012 3.047518 0.0024
0.7 0.306553 0.053388 5.741985 0
0.8 0.539157 0.057776 9.331938 0
0.9 0.467968 0.128679 3.636704 0.0003
0.95 0.220158 0.066064 3.332503 0.0009
0.99 -0.45168 0.207724 -2.17442 0.0299
157
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: CCI C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.083994 0.006182 -13.58775 0
0.1 -0.071311 0.003478 -20.50619 0
0.2 -0.032048 0.002958 -10.835 0
0.3 -0.025636 0.002254 -11.37416 0
0.4 -0.031504 0.001603 -19.65081 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.00167 -18.8609 0
0.6 -0.031504 0.001603 -19.65081 0
0.7 -0.013791 0.003605 -3.825263 0.0001
0.8 -0.001526 0.008284 -0.184198 0.8539
0.9 0.017746 0.004161 4.265191 0
0.95 0.023629 0.005028 4.699772 0
0.99 0.035258 0.003704 9.519831 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.260157 0.140477 1.85195 0.0643
0.1 0.198324 0.085387 2.322648 0.0204
0.2 0.692337 0.075337 9.189882 0
0.3 0.491606 0.094892 5.180667 0
0.4 1.11E-16 0.051952 2.14E-15 1
0.5 3.70E-32 0.054125 6.83E-31 1
0.6 5.47E-48 0.051952 1.05E-46 1
0.7 0.32095 0.091749 3.498136 0.0005
0.8 0.260227 0.280446 0.927906 0.3536
0.9 0.207885 0.145004 1.433652 0.1519
0.95 -0.158313 0.142133 -1.113835 0.2656
0.99 0.009423 0.105642 0.089196 0.9289
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: DAG C VNINDEX
158
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.069181 0.002944 -23.50184 0
0.1 -0.054376 0.006979 -7.790972 0
0.2 -0.025936 0.00251 -10.33197 0
0.3 -0.021343 0.002978 -7.167945 0
0.4 -0.022532 0.002451 -9.19226 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.001799 -17.50916 0
0.6 -0.017783 0.002332 -7.62429 0
0.7 -0.007177 0.002963 -2.422086 0.0156
0.8 0.006059 0.004644 1.304757 0.1922
0.9 0.022791 0.003941 5.782317 0
0.95 0.031911 0.004967 6.424095 0
0.99 0.035023 0.003664 9.558297 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.306399 0.087489 3.502159 0.0005
0.1 0.47906 0.154627 3.098161 0.002
0.2 0.810741 0.070641 11.47688 0
0.3 0.648918 0.115469 5.619849 0
0.4 0.395105 0.082494 4.789498 0
0.5 2.22E-16 0.05384 4.12E-15 1
0.6 0.338047 0.068784 4.914581 0
0.7 0.486446 0.079581 6.112613 0
0.8 0.546551 0.127105 4.30001 0
0.9 0.521955 0.141436 3.690397 0.0002
0.95 0.458516 0.139163 3.294809 0.001
0.99 0.06357 0.144063 0.441264 0.6591
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: DSN C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
159
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.035827 0.002668 -13.4305 0
0.1 -0.030849 0.001964 -15.71036 0
0.2 -0.029212 0.001265 -23.0952 0
0.3 -0.026669 0.001152 -23.1532 0
0.4 -0.028198 0.001051 -26.82494 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.000958 -32.8882 0
0.6 -0.025381 0.001337 -18.98922 0
0.7 -0.01609 0.001563 -10.29179 0
0.8 -0.011331 0.002039 -5.557992 0
0.9 0.002754 0.003986 0.690885 0.4898
0.95 0.017871 0.00379 4.714721 0
0.99 0.01873 0.00248 7.552609 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.651575 0.06224 10.46873 0
0.1 0.559547 0.074784 7.482181 0
0.2 0.351033 0.042912 8.180362 0
0.3 0.29531 0.043629 6.768647 0
0.4 0.137008 0.034946 3.920583 0.0001
0.5 5.55E-17 0.030007 1.85E-15 1
0.6 0.149831 0.039471 3.796022 0.0002
0.7 0.317917 0.042362 7.50474 0
0.8 0.332021 0.056853 5.840026 0
0.9 0.455604 0.091464 4.981247 0
0.95 0.562827 0.128228 4.389273 0
0.99 0.090948 0.124022 0.733324 0.4635
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: VNA C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
160
C 0.05 -0.064149 0.003274 -19.59098 0
0.1 -0.054377 0.002901 -18.7454 0
0.2 -0.041422 0.005298 -7.819129 0
0.3 -0.018945 0.002768 -6.844755 0
0.4 -0.016514 0.002936 -5.624973 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.002877 -10.94983 0
0.6 -0.015952 0.003452 -4.621564 0
0.7 0.008896 0.002964 3.001037 0.0027
0.8 0.01783 0.003497 5.098463 0
0.9 0.017284 0.002833 6.100998 0
0.95 0.027155 0.00487 5.576054 0
0.99 0.036566 0.008071 4.530751 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.488354 0.083991 5.814371 0
0.1 0.546075 0.081149 6.729279 0
0.2 0.642006 0.135059 4.75353 0
0.3 0.886276 0.087471 10.13228 0
0.4 0.625443 0.097954 6.385056 0
0.5 3.33E-16 0.090806 3.67E-15 1
0.6 0.425039 0.104833 4.054437 0.0001
0.7 0.895307 0.073435 12.19178 0
0.8 0.721376 0.136017 5.303573 0
0.9 0.4027 0.097501 4.130224 0
0.95 0.50344 0.144852 3.47556 0.0005
0.99 0.134206 0.27871 0.481526 0.6302
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: CLW C VNINDEX
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
0.8 0.9 0.95 0.99
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.071275 0.005981 -11.91628 0
0.1 -0.058166 0.003566 -16.31281 0
161
0.2 -0.028996 0.002522 -11.49732 0
0.3 -0.026399 0.001906 -13.85131 0
0.4 -0.031504 0.001274 -24.72506 0
0.5 -0.031504 0.001334 -23.61324 0
0.6 -0.031504 0.001274 -24.72506 0
0.7 -0.009934 0.003382 -2.93696 0.0034
0.8 0.00679 0.003584 1.894458 0.0584
0.9 0.019762 0.003005 6.575355 0
0.95 0.024378 0.004877 4.998341 0
0.99 0.048442 0.005121 9.460074 0
VNINDEX 0.05 0.246395 0.176934 1.392584 0.164
0.1 0.329602 0.084891 3.882648 0.0001
0.2 0.589392 0.077766 7.579053 0
0.3 0.293695 0.074064 3.965396 0.0001
0.4 5.55E-17 0.038571 1.44E-15 1
0.5 1.23E-32 0.040408 3.05E-31 1
0.6 2.74E-48 0.038571 7.10E-47 1
0.7 0.434096 0.080911 5.365132 0
0.8 0.580746 0.098683 5.884962 0
0.9 0.512091 0.087662 5.841663 0
0.95 0.331163 0.136359 2.428618 0.0153
0.99 0.644951 0.130892 4.927338 0
162
PHỤ LỤC 7
KẾT QUẢ ƯỚC LƯỢNG MÔ HÌNH FAMA-FRENCH VỚI YẾU TỐ
NGÀNH BẰNG PHƯƠNG PHÁP ƯỚC LƯỢNG HỒI QUY PHÂN VỊ
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: AGR C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.06396688 0.007147995 -8.9489261 1.37E-18
0.1 -0.05135184 0.005854926 -8.77070778 6.13E-18
0.2 -0.03599363 0.004777178 -7.53449653 9.76E-14
0.3 -0.03152805 0.004726488 -6.67050353 3.92E-11
0.4 -0.02292108 0.004344401 -5.27600542 1.57E-07
0.5 -0.01718146 0.003788132 -4.53560296 6.33E-06
0.6 -0.01399702 0.003594428 -3.89408941 1.04E-04
0.7 -0.01031293 0.003496295 -2.94967223 0.003244164
0.8 -0.00499464 0.00449993 -1.10993757 0.267253223
0.9 0.001607796 0.005620279 0.286070413 0.774874661
0.95 0.006921538 0.009106315 0.760081125 0.447358702
RM_RF 0.05 0.303901868 0.196386886 1.547465179 0.122020624
0.1 0.402738614 0.179840847 2.239416801 0.025315463
0.2 0.54866186 0.14230199 3.855616221 0.0001217
0.3 0.455327017 0.144561082 3.149720603 1.68E-03
0.4 0.511933268 0.131125668 3.90414229 9.99E-05
0.5 0.511630096 0.116579742 4.388670688 1.24E-05
0.6 0.440816953 0.111356594 3.958606653 7.99E-05
0.7 0.377798491 0.107007314 3.530585671 0.000430704
0.8 0.338366962 0.141744792 2.387156225 0.017136794
0.9 0.1726537 0.171441526 1.007070483 0.31410842
0.95 0.025790942 0.294010478 0.087721166 0.930113256
163
SMB 0.05 0.177064631 0.176806521 1.001459848 0.316810907
0.1 0.135507828 0.130887077 1.035303344 0.300740472
0.2 0.077179031 0.080690584 0.956481252 0.339026066
0.3 -0.05000071 0.097495905 -0.51284936 0.608153182
0.4 0.101881291 0.100351555 1.015243764 0.310198824
0.5 0.043665112 0.102199758 0.427252601 0.669273699
0.6 -0.00827242 0.100436969 -0.08236433 0.934371042
0.7 -0.13577589 0.091567199 -1.48280056 0.138395788
0.8 -0.08159357 0.102726197 -0.79428199 0.427191809
0.9 0.214355685 0.133774753 1.602362777 0.109344414
0.95 0.284409861 0.267589325 1.062859519 0.288064238
HML 0.05 -0.07814442 0.128690875 -0.60722583 0.543818471
0.1 -0.17706232 0.103346961 -1.71328039 0.086924975
0.2 -0.04744779 0.097193672 -0.48817774 0.625515115
0.3 -0.0864772 0.088772623 -0.97414263 0.330186396
0.4 -0.087726 0.086473967 -1.01447876 0.310563386
0.5 -0.04453631 0.078471386 -0.56754844 5.70E-01
0.6 0.002435771 0.072956559 0.033386589 9.73E-01
0.7 -0.03808861 0.066275681 -0.57469962 5.66E-01
0.8 -0.00031245 0.062866748 -0.00497009 9.96E-01
0.9 -0.10493214 0.076773024 -1.36678405 1.72E-01
0.95 -0.09182413 0.185873578 -0.49401389 6.21E-01
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.516916815 0.124829689 4.140976557 3.71E-05
0.1 0.627027304 0.135692954 4.620927526 4.24E-06
0.2 0.594766137 0.085005093 6.996829433 4.39E-12
0.3 0.616718243 0.089292371 6.906729363 8.11E-12
0.4 0.603146135 0.095653218 6.305549832 4.06E-10
0.5 0.53579165 0.087653281 6.112625113 1.33E-09
0.6 0.605470335 0.086294923 7.016291509 3.84E-12
0.7 0.588211794 0.083371736 7.05529023 2.94E-12
0.8 0.623623671 0.098171923 6.35236282 3.03E-10
0.9 0.734612518 0.099428208 7.388371289 2.81E-13
0.95 0.747459311 0.176026385 4.246291319 2.35E-05
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: BVH C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
164
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.03069769 0.008630624 -3.55683333 0.000390308
0.1 -0.00657314 0.005414735 -1.21393637 0.225016169
0.2 0.000620739 0.004502397 0.137868567 0.890367935
0.3 0.005387271 0.003668426 1.468550967 0.142222501
0.4 0.011185467 0.003370497 3.318639708 0.000932322
0.5 0.011642593 0.003481337 3.344287835 8.51E-04
0.6 0.020243665 0.003759012 5.385369314 8.73E-08
0.7 0.026881374 0.003560196 7.550532755 8.68E-14
0.8 0.029320334 0.004120944 7.114956289 1.94E-12
0.9 0.043142209 0.005087441 8.480139839 6.67E-17
0.95 0.052544362 0.004239521 12.39393919 3.06E-33
RM_RF 0.05 1.16147107 0.22102685 5.25488678 1.76E-07
0.1 1.570178285 0.158644856 9.897442132 3.08E-22
0.2 1.513981025 0.141044452 10.73407001 1.05E-25
0.3 1.493969049 0.111603153 13.38644128 3.89E-38
0.4 1.530164916 0.102920441 14.86745397 6.13E-46
0.5 1.425554941 0.104268055 13.67202005 1.35E-39
0.6 1.575990951 0.110542294 14.25690473 1.18E-42
0.7 1.63231725 0.106541583 15.32094051 1.94E-48
0.8 1.491841171 0.134820189 11.06541369 3.84E-27
0.9 1.528369055 0.132244876 11.55711363 2.46E-29
0.95 1.55374457 0.114975654 13.51368327 8.76E-39
SMB 0.05 -0.14316533 0.159290541 -0.89876855 0.368960248
0.1 0.001225517 0.112840949 0.010860571 0.991336512
0.2 0.01000747 0.079531822 0.125829762 0.899888226
0.3 0.054364052 0.077290016 0.703377415 0.481960042
0.4 0.105163593 0.069282768 1.517889593 0.129311459
0.5 0.040653396 0.069150617 0.587896364 0.55671492
0.6 0.031284281 0.071615468 0.436836921 0.662309953
0.7 -0.04906844 0.059805737 -0.82046383 0.412118295
165
0.8 -0.05056633 0.10457876 -0.48352387 0.628813983
0.9 -0.11122838 0.174268039 -0.63826033 0.523428711
0.95 0.114412518 0.219346524 0.521606251 0.602042895
HML 0.05 0.057534234 0.088576703 0.649541384 0.516115566
0.1 0.001411534 0.070932492 0.019899685 0.984126767
0.2 -0.11929456 0.057770138 -2.06498662 0.039143417
0.3 -0.11508632 0.056266924 -2.04536366 0.041041548
0.4 -0.10098694 0.055703659 -1.81293186 0.070097636
0.5 -0.08535783 0.053233379 -1.6034644 0.109101141
0.6 -0.06597472 0.059967497 -1.10017473 0.271481535
0.7 -0.0900707 0.080557825 -1.1180875 0.263758363
0.8 -0.07511867 0.073114542 -1.02741085 0.304438678
0.9 0.054692246 0.100290124 0.545340297 0.585623083
0.95 -0.0072215 0.110713954 -0.06522661 0.948004679
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.077819448 0.126742544 0.613996257 0.539336755
0.1 0.071302744 0.111202339 0.641198239 0.521519043
0.2 0.178807603 0.083173999 2.149801676 0.031774716
0.3 0.204915327 0.074262333 2.759344053 0.005881792
0.4 0.189485595 0.074300511 2.550259626 0.010890398
0.5 0.221878549 0.077161241 2.875518152 0.004106492
0.6 0.160960039 0.076227156 2.111583939 0.034933009
0.7 0.124809281 0.075849604 1.645483617 0.100137797
0.8 0.257256077 0.090240668 2.850777628 0.004437562
0.9 0.179297387 0.105784781 1.694926104 0.090354628
0.95 0.206212662 0.110950546 1.858599792 0.063334003
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: CTG C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.03862058 0.00384919 -10.0334297 8.73E-23
166
0.1 -0.03176358 0.002495879 -12.7264099 7.53E-35
0.2 -0.0246865 0.002553009 -9.66957038 2.47E-21
0.3 -0.02222677 0.00261685 -8.49371113 5.98E-17
0.4 -0.02109641 0.002409747 -8.75461744 7.01E-18
0.5 -0.01972522 0.002472791 -7.97690761 3.54E-15
0.6 -0.01653506 0.002830884 -5.84095462 6.71E-09
0.7 -0.0138387 0.003867047 -3.57862163 0.000359496
0.8 -0.00908511 0.006293558 -1.44355628 1.49E-01
0.9 -0.00436381 0.003298466 -1.32298239 1.86E-01
0.95 0.003450662 0.004754959 0.725697369 4.68E-01
RM_RF 0.05 0.575304342 0.12026117 4.783791313 1.94E-06
0.1 0.565125579 0.071154553 7.942226549 4.62E-15
0.2 0.593013047 0.076215485 7.780742246 1.57E-14
0.3 0.529139443 0.08453807 6.259185245 5.42E-10
0.4 0.474664873 0.075448626 6.291232789 4.44E-10
0.5 0.426812004 0.077164591 5.531189854 3.92E-08
0.6 0.430149756 0.087769188 4.900919858 1.09E-06
0.7 0.392425529 0.118317845 3.316706183 0.000938736
0.8 0.363953719 0.200061788 1.819206568 0.069134555
0.9 0.214897751 0.105028803 2.046083975 0.040970515
0.95 0.217043653 0.148540388 1.461176018 0.144234726
SMB 0.05 0.194048219 0.123674825 1.569019557 0.116912852
0.1 -0.0069892 0.081078652 -0.0862027 0.931319982
0.2 0.06211657 0.060694674 1.023427023 0.30631682
0.3 0.065130284 0.039571041 1.645907741 0.100050417
0.4 0.065755192 0.039494336 1.664927163 0.09619411
0.5 0.053012974 0.046096745 1.150037252 0.250362736
0.6 0.090666402 0.059168619 1.532339325 0.125708134
0.7 0.016549588 0.072165194 0.229329218 0.818652991
0.8 0.061755335 0.086521329 0.713758518 0.475518383
0.9 0.057274115 0.105702106 0.541844593 0.588028388
0.95 0.028723279 0.235298146 0.122071844 0.902863012
HML 0.05 0.03441321 0.096542889 0.356455154 0.721563781
0.1 -0.02701861 0.072737706 -0.37145258 0.710367492
0.2 -0.02573039 0.040286496 -0.6386853 5.23E-01
0.3 0.013946045 0.034376814 0.405681711 6.85E-01
0.4 0.031784689 0.03582453 0.887232561 3.75E-01
167
0.5 0.07179886 0.03763495 1.907770837 5.67E-02
0.6 0.063133152 0.046438896 1.359488647 1.74E-01
0.7 0.08664715 0.056971448 1.520887272 1.29E-01
0.8 0.158892641 0.074760973 2.125342084 3.38E-02
0.9 0.097860428 0.107004531 0.914544714 0.360618485
0.95 0.133963782 0.08951014 1.496632474 1.35E-01
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.511846384 0.057783044 8.858072333 2.95E-18
0.1 0.407674839 0.051689048 7.887064235 7.04E-15
0.2 0.343210467 0.057351668 5.98431534 2.88E-09
0.3 0.302828531 0.053094775 5.70354671 1.48E-08
0.4 0.350851993 0.054642556 6.42085619 1.96E-10
0.5 0.353358487 0.059073393 5.981686024 2.93E-09
0.6 0.388556733 0.069414141 5.597659584 2.70E-08
0.7 0.41722317 0.083248483 5.011781048 6.22E-07
0.8 0.51228102 0.13484284 3.799096938 0.000152666
0.9 0.67325222 0.073275387 9.187972164 1.76E-19
0.95 0.710354193 0.083952793 8.461352673 7.77E-17
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: EIB C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.04540846 0.003817794 -11.8938998 6.98E-31
0.1 -0.03647861 0.00339956 -10.7303934 1.09E-25
0.2 -0.02979561 0.002428899 -12.2671272 1.23E-32
0.3 -0.02801518 0.002132614 -13.1365457 7.06E-37
0.4 -0.02683804 0.002421643 -11.0825752 3.23E-27
0.5 -0.02520192 0.001959371 -12.8622486 1.62E-35
0.6 -0.02239476 0.001678491 -13.3421971 6.52E-38
0.7 -0.02084565 0.001703583 -12.2363567 1.72E-32
0.8 -0.01952588 0.001950907 -10.0086163 1.10E-22
168
0.9 -0.0115343 0.003347369 -3.44577994 0.000589535
0.95 -0.00686226 0.003266895 -2.10054526 3.59E-02
RM_RF 0.05 0.233320947 0.102574357 2.274651813 2.31E-02
0.1 0.30942604 0.096451757 3.208091281 0.001372311
0.2 0.370091433 0.073660804 5.02426544 5.84E-07
0.3 0.291238326 0.068721278 4.237964318 2.43E-05
0.4 0.244436391 0.077068927 3.171659443 0.001554974
0.5 0.210516821 0.060175164 3.49840045 0.000485572
0.6 0.223538233 0.051684305 4.325069882 1.65E-05
0.7 0.198787629 0.053164021 3.739138359 0.000193554
0.8 0.135367885 0.061126717 2.214545319 0.026982773
0.9 0.182523586 0.104667407 1.743843577 0.081448109
0.95 0.103318996 0.102100929 1.011930025 0.311780019
SMB 0.05 0.043921849 0.093522033 0.469641723 0.638698225
0.1 0.044269608 0.046175586 0.958723267 0.337895568
0.2 0.088906728 0.035507381 2.503894268 0.01241832
0.3 0.070363812 0.049486125 1.421889723 0.155323869
0.4 0.069994146 0.050529758 1.385206418 0.166252493
0.5 -0.00989136 0.047656963 -0.20755329 0.835613775
0.6 -0.05066167 0.041330204 -1.22577837 0.220527917
0.7 -0.01785168 0.042343406 -0.42159293 0.67339935
0.8 -0.05879768 0.055217247 -1.06484259 0.28716612
0.9 0.066560009 0.141348664 0.47089238 0.637805069
0.95 0.12707156 0.094410059 1.345953605 0.178577326
HML 0.05 0.015557405 0.128785642 0.120800774 0.903869508
0.1 0.0851745 0.047940763 1.776661342 0.07588288
0.2 0.066159419 0.034207261 1.934075332 0.053343956
0.3 0.075678244 0.037425612 2.022097715 4.34E-02
0.4 0.071641098 0.034529766 2.074763502 3.82E-02
0.5 0.055728658 0.029414394 1.894605012 5.84E-02
0.6 0.085263927 0.028897124 2.950602543 3.23E-03
0.7 0.088265028 0.031436655 2.807710558 5.07E-03
0.8 0.091039141 0.042827941 2.125695024 3.37E-02
0.9 0.116957884 0.082445098 1.418615373 1.56E-01
0.95 0.08359432 0.067015087 1.247395525 2.13E-01
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.443998595 0.088928767 4.992744327 6.85E-07
0.1 0.29497047 0.065211152 4.523313316 6.71E-06
169
0.2 0.222268038 0.047977193 4.632785418 4.01E-06
0.3 0.182223109 0.039551592 4.607225604 4.53E-06
0.4 0.179796438 0.04192274 4.288756818 1.94E-05
0.5 0.163125125 0.037873217 4.307136702 1.79E-05
0.6 0.167577832 0.036352167 4.609844423 4.47E-06
0.7 0.195790665 0.038002789 5.152007835 3.02E-07
0.8 0.267024272 0.046219931 5.777253854 9.72E-09
0.9 0.346127481 0.088576898 3.907649594 9.85E-05
0.95 0.548128709 0.093258296 5.877532991 5.42E-09
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: SSI C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.03664161 0.002644643 -13.8550311 1.53E-40
0.1 -0.0375867 0.003019332 -12.4486797 1.67E-33
0.2 -0.03022333 0.002546763 -11.8673513 9.27E-31
0.3 -0.02620426 0.002838495 -9.23174437 1.21E-19
0.4 -0.02415672 0.002998984 -8.05496994 1.94E-15
0.5 -0.0225808 0.003209927 -7.03467556 3.39E-12
0.6 -0.02317031 0.003141981 -7.37442788 3.11E-13
0.7 -0.02136172 0.003009448 -7.09822072 2.18E-12
0.8 -0.01703333 0.003060152 -5.56617111 3.22E-08
0.9 -0.01103801 0.001898846 -5.81301045 7.90E-09
0.95 -0.00142274 0.003422183 -0.41574133 6.78E-01
RM_RF 0.05 0.550357035 0.083373421 6.601108929 6.17E-11
0.1 0.408039217 0.093218029 4.377256421 1.31E-05
0.2 0.403654648 0.076888081 5.249898882 1.81E-07
0.3 0.407555876 0.087939738 4.634490456 3.98E-06
0.4 0.383611322 0.09462569 4.05398706 5.37E-05
0.5 0.335726226 0.101794818 3.298067934 0.001002705
170
0.6 0.226918626 0.099225555 2.286897006 2.24E-02
0.7 0.179933006 0.092293671 1.949570364 0.051465176
0.8 0.198934244 0.089445415 2.224085435 0.026332333
0.9 0.216288442 0.055224902 3.916502047 9.50E-05
0.95 0.340302257 0.091249061 3.729378159 0.000201115
SMB 0.05 -0.13178515 0.051892562 -2.53957696 0.011226779
0.1 -0.06237568 0.05624498 -1.10900001 0.267657301
0.2 -0.04506819 0.046467896 -0.96987791 0.332307119
0.3 -0.05588277 0.059782245 -0.93477206 0.350098004
0.4 -0.05080261 0.062252005 -0.81607997 0.414619946
0.5 -0.07795678 0.057875441 -1.34697518 0.178248169
0.6 -0.04562636 0.053608493 -0.85110316 0.39488561
0.7 -0.07627755 0.050665179 -1.50552211 0.132458887
0.8 -0.09853429 0.055568905 -1.77319119 0.076456254
0.9 -0.07905108 0.063051117 -1.25376176 0.210178213
0.95 -0.06179941 0.095404007 -0.6477654 0.517263352
HML 0.05 -0.13061673 0.056315461 -2.31937595 0.02054558
0.1 -0.13696082 0.055121385 -2.48471298 0.013104103
0.2 -0.0176604 0.055280059 -0.31947138 0.749425929
0.3 -0.01831637 0.041963351 -0.43648499 6.63E-01
0.4 -0.01813342 0.039870149 -0.45481203 6.49E-01
0.5 -0.01887934 0.038121536 -0.49524091 6.21E-01
0.6 -0.00524658 0.040442168 -0.12973042 8.97E-01
0.7 0.010539736 0.044338884 0.237708653 8.12E-01
0.8 -0.02040608 0.051943989 -0.39284779 6.95E-01
0.9 -0.05931349 0.05973931 -0.99287198 3.21E-01
0.95 -0.04681162 0.060505425 -0.77367641 4.39E-01
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.599834198 0.04248118 14.1199985 6.27E-42
0.1 0.685548164 0.047793566 14.34394267 4.08E-43
0.2 0.740965374 0.058173622 12.73713668 6.67E-35
0.3 0.737754975 0.065947964 11.18692581 1.12E-27
0.4 0.783739193 0.068534438 11.43569892 8.69E-29
0.5 0.812501879 0.079472258 10.223717 1.46E-23
0.6 0.92835092 0.07873432 11.79093089 2.09E-30
0.7 0.98089851 0.07344035 13.35639761 5.52E-38
0.8 0.990699406 0.068821011 14.39530451 2.17E-43
0.9 0.984182113 0.037518385 26.23199555 9.63E-120
171
0.95 0.864654864 0.048980019 17.65321613 4.87E-62
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: STB C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.04885987 0.005452484 -8.96102974 1.24E-18
0.1 -0.03537891 0.002683123 -13.1857201 4.00E-37
0.2 -0.03033186 0.003179192 -9.54074511 7.88E-21
0.3 -0.02725405 0.003194776 -8.5308168 4.42E-17
0.4 -0.02391445 0.00248291 -9.63162207 3.48E-21
0.5 -0.02025697 0.002452809 -8.25868401 3.93E-16
0.6 -0.01628004 0.003011001 -5.40685163 7.77E-08
0.7 -0.01357687 0.003841633 -3.53413976 0.000425014
0.8 -0.0071416 0.004208019 -1.69714038 0.089935176
0.9 0.005524516 0.007221832 0.764974399 4.44E-01
0.95 0.008219501 0.007859194 1.045845191 2.96E-01
RM_RF 0.05 0.387679497 0.145339417 2.667407817 7.75E-03
0.1 0.54148302 0.077470524 6.98953602 4.61E-12
0.2 0.474359624 0.097422323 4.869106057 1.27E-06
0.3 0.40179241 0.101212223 3.969801257 7.63E-05
0.4 0.392248098 0.076366178 5.136411293 3.28E-07
0.5 0.414924753 0.074653919 5.557976873 3.38E-08
0.6 0.42859081 0.092518897 4.632467792 4.02E-06
0.7 0.378007049 0.11760477 3.214215275 0.001343626
0.8 0.383997959 0.12307032 3.120150804 0.001851654
0.9 0.426563986 0.218890429 1.948755766 0.051562546
0.95 0.202926542 0.234638766 0.86484661 0.387299662
SMB 0.05 0.303640677 0.132340264 2.29439377 0.021943747
0.1 0.197152683 0.106126065 1.8577216 0.063458783
0.2 0.093869384 0.064765941 1.449363399 0.147503184
172
0.3 0.027297399 0.065363635 0.417623633 0.676298679
0.4 -0.02085858 0.056720082 -0.367746 0.713128925
0.5 -0.00628075 0.04944273 -0.12703076 0.898937807
0.6 0.004109882 0.047364745 0.086770914 0.930868403
0.7 0.031087002 0.056143559 0.55370559 0.579885787
0.8 0.010966282 0.106260022 0.103202328 0.917820018
0.9 0.031437372 0.208748589 0.150599209 0.880317756
0.95 -0.05381716 0.224521401 -0.23969722 0.81060683
HML 0.05 -0.00533591 0.115949014 -0.04601947 0.963302551
0.1 0.032342254 0.070604023 0.458079472 0.64698012
0.2 -0.07756377 0.055646729 -1.39386038 0.163623541
0.3 -0.09143688 0.046818842 -1.95299325 0.051057713
0.4 -0.0813094 0.043488841 -1.86966134 0.061779618
0.5 -0.04253534 0.044660494 -0.9524154 3.41E-01
0.6 -0.06999744 0.050021847 -1.39933727 1.62E-01
0.7 -0.01473487 0.049680215 -0.29659425 7.67E-01
0.8 0.006492248 0.082895425 0.078318527 0.937588025
0.9 -0.05019695 0.155800103 -0.32218817 0.747367511
0.95 -0.26670913 0.12965963 -2.05699437 0.039907302
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.382436797 0.08488868 4.505156614 7.29E-06
0.1 0.218362205 0.061187579 3.568734208 0.000373185
0.2 0.277353035 0.074056361 3.745161552 0.000189023
0.3 0.236790698 0.055655697 4.254563531 2.26E-05
0.4 0.208778406 0.044334958 4.709114765 2.78E-06
0.5 0.176212601 0.044445091 3.964725843 7.79E-05
0.6 0.182177056 0.054960269 3.31470459 0.00094542
0.7 0.263722857 0.083061693 3.175023849 0.001537211
0.8 0.249951346 0.081902408 3.051819258 0.002325687
0.9 0.360304683 0.129351868 2.785461778 0.005431134
0.95 0.372562448 0.196978271 1.891388558 0.058818467
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: VCB C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
173
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.02159321 0.002566154 -8.41462 1.13E-16
0.1 -0.01703159 0.002474235 -6.88357691 9.48E-12
0.2 -0.01312245 0.002580966 -5.08431677 4.29E-07
0.3 -0.00867262 0.002649563 -3.27322698 0.001094251
0.4 -0.00528707 0.002352121 -2.24778858 0.024774693
0.5 -0.00257933 0.002502228 -1.03081394 0.30284039
0.6 -0.00029127 0.00283878 -0.10260505 0.91829396
0.7 0.003384656 0.00333707 1.014259658 0.310667849
0.8 0.006732599 0.003656692 1.841172085 0.065848524
0.9 0.011194701 0.004107316 2.725551489 6.51E-03
0.95 0.00942852 0.005800332 1.625513965 1.04E-01
RM_RF 0.05 1.023463339 0.076729417 13.33860448 6.80E-38
0.1 1.023524801 0.074702887 13.70127507 9.54E-40
0.2 0.965713967 0.078222409 12.34574572 5.20E-33
0.3 0.964296623 0.07847073 12.28861548 9.73E-33
0.4 0.957749311 0.071276499 13.43709804 2.15E-38
0.5 0.957404041 0.076446677 12.52381499 7.26E-34
0.6 0.933253271 0.086993642 10.72783308 1.12E-25
0.7 0.941300798 0.102883414 9.149198665 2.47E-19
0.8 0.867540514 0.119028037 7.288539176 5.74E-13
0.9 0.758208028 0.124573996 6.086406907 1.56E-09
0.95 0.456468718 0.192574171 2.370352762 0.017931956
SMB 0.05 0.236201078 0.101211854 2.333729374 0.019777976
0.1 0.133327976 0.069042166 1.931109399 0.05371004
0.2 0.16924939 0.063275978 2.674781106 0.007581713
0.3 0.143635231 0.057482617 2.49875943 0.012598712
0.4 0.063581774 0.050067895 1.269911071 0.204367952
0.5 0.048612033 0.050947969 0.954150553 0.340203854
0.6 0.015765256 0.054924398 0.28703558 0.774135728
0.7 0.010428321 0.049776012 0.209504962 0.83409041
0.8 -0.013089 0.076651997 -0.1707588 0.864442848
0.9 -0.1250734 0.084668326 -1.47721595 0.139885955
0.95 -0.28628768 0.156825448 -1.825518 0.068176843
174
HML 0.05 -0.12609733 0.06030839 -2.09087535 0.036753826
0.1 -0.05249601 0.061857633 -0.84865862 0.39624428
0.2 -0.02856029 0.052724988 -0.54168414 0.588138903
0.3 0.008970967 0.045691263 0.196338783 8.44E-01
0.4 0.044155586 0.03641604 1.212531261 2.26E-01
0.5 0.052177521 0.03461011 1.507580346 0.131931
0.6 0.007977422 0.038396899 0.20776213 0.835450737
0.7 -0.02601827 0.041061953 -0.63363449 0.526442812
0.8 0.009589424 0.063181145 0.151776681 0.879389152
0.9 0.03090853 0.100577447 0.307310746 0.758661361
0.95 0.023297202 0.11291263 0.206329459 0.836569345
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.349122837 0.049919617 6.9937003 4.49E-12
0.1 0.278288999 0.056995073 4.882685164 1.19E-06
0.2 0.265415987 0.05632031 4.712615894 2.74E-06
0.3 0.220911966 0.060567219 3.647385015 0.000276538
0.4 0.16732387 0.053467417 3.129454893 0.001794481
0.5 0.184012982 0.056177028 3.275591247 0.001085216
0.6 0.210892375 0.060575655 3.481470824 0.000516989
0.7 0.214630875 0.060880769 3.525429745 0.000439085
0.8 0.294837922 0.08264434 3.567551298 0.000374855
0.9 0.370429999 0.072389735 5.117161977 3.62E-07
0.95 0.532817428 0.107288054 4.966232578 7.84E-07
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: BSI C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.07391068 0.005576196 -13.2546765 3.58E-37
0.1 -0.06068761 0.007071957 -8.58144468 3.35E-17
0.2 -0.05280211 0.007071857 -7.46651221 1.74E-13
0.3 -0.03693132 0.005839205 -6.32471671 3.76E-10
175
0.4 -0.03250346 0.005079611 -6.39880841 2.36E-10
0.5 -0.02819226 0.004947993 -5.69771639 1.58E-08
0.6 -0.01618291 0.005085328 -3.1822737 0.001504421
0.7 -0.00945727 0.006047139 -1.56392457 0.118138625
0.8 -0.00393098 0.00723561 -0.54328295 0.587051086
0.9 0.005329567 0.005704552 0.934265659 0.350383112
0.95 0.021909737 0.00909118 2.409999099 0.016124841
RM_RF 0.05 0.149251615 0.159189415 0.937572479 0.348681208
0.1 0.271899118 0.211138283 1.28777744 0.198109096
0.2 0.135830526 0.209810382 0.647396593 0.517517763
0.3 0.29253531 0.178511309 1.63874945 0.101567039
0.4 0.207760521 0.155639369 1.334884107 0.182205579
0.5 0.17052707 0.149244167 1.142604592 0.253465014
0.6 0.321410133 0.150404073 2.136977589 0.03283193
0.7 0.31709474 0.180654906 1.755251195 0.079509908
0.8 0.164718635 0.224506872 0.733690841 0.463302066
0.9 0.056583419 0.182614187 0.309852261 0.756735203
0.95 0.195334387 0.265775213 0.73496089 0.462528528
SMB 0.05 -0.10188297 0.203022196 -0.50183169 0.615891834
0.1 -0.06632433 0.160679554 -0.41277395 0.679857075
0.2 -0.05515479 0.150325403 -0.36690264 0.713766063
0.3 -0.23379016 0.11901953 -1.96430085 0.049760435
0.4 -0.29190936 0.118522494 -2.46290262 0.013942408
0.5 -0.20299905 0.127692519 -1.58974898 0.112194447
0.6 -0.2271692 0.128257689 -1.77119362 0.076820497
0.7 -0.20334215 0.112012729 -1.81534863 0.069757434
0.8 -0.18176221 0.107944185 -1.68385368 0.092509172
0.9 -0.08134748 0.124246269 -0.65472772 0.512787431
0.95 -0.1972757 0.19315625 -1.02132702 0.307336358
HML 0.05 -0.03046424 0.129614659 -0.23503702 0.814226139
0.1 0.076989687 0.155714893 0.494427256 0.621108588
0.2 -0.04025251 0.12460002 -0.32305379 0.746719258
0.3 0.030064518 0.091342405 0.329140865 0.742115297
0.4 0.083808377 0.094811922 0.883943446 3.77E-01
0.5 0.06148935 0.096275705 0.638679826 5.23E-01
0.6 0.142915392 0.101202885 1.412167177 1.58E-01
0.7 0.063821533 0.111929638 0.570193329 5.69E-01
176
0.8 0.071199549 0.13522266 0.526535634 5.99E-01
0.9 -0.06212272 0.128067049 -0.48507968 6.28E-01
0.95 -0.16135601 0.167410869 -0.96383233 3.35E-01
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.303977026 0.107084511 2.83866475 4.62E-03
0.1 0.407220354 0.143940899 2.829080239 0.004757672
0.2 0.658174793 0.151581226 4.342060106 1.55E-05
0.3 0.587458489 0.115499891 5.086225484 4.33E-07
0.4 0.561700201 0.104794966 5.359992232 1.02E-07
0.5 0.571787559 0.110980043 5.152165606 3.08E-07
0.6 0.526091392 0.119387137 4.406600267 1.16E-05
0.7 0.586055579 0.136677669 4.287866372 1.97E-05
0.8 0.648736318 0.143695361 4.514664303 7.06E-06
0.9 0.638774639 0.122202945 5.227162395 2.08E-07
0.95 0.383055114 0.131113987 2.921542718 0.003558098
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: SII C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.09940268 0.006809433 -14.5977906 1.10E-42
0.1 -0.05786021 0.017764058 -3.25715065 0.001175791
0.2 -0.03228416 0.012411037 -2.60124615 9.47E-03
0.3 -0.02703896 0.004897196 -5.52131502 4.63E-08
0.4 -0.02519003 0.004469553 -5.63591784 2.46E-08
0.5 -0.0315036 0.004419597 -7.12816103 2.39E-12
0.6 -0.0233429 0.004454494 -5.24030274 2.08E-07
0.7 -0.01832339 0.007229177 -2.53464475 0.011457578
0.8 -0.01852275 0.011298686 -1.63937164 0.10155357
0.9 -0.00382054 0.008463378 -0.45141984 0.651816966
0.95 0.023041466 0.007865477 2.929442907 0.003498305
RM_RF 0.05 0.033101979 0.195687552 0.169157306 0.86571834
177
0.1 0.540663544 0.523087229 1.033601117 0.301654514
0.2 5.84E-01 0.385552744 1.52E+00 0.130031352
0.3 0.374183701 0.153282054 2.44114487 0.014870095
0.4 0.256864872 0.142783278 1.798984278 0.072421474
0.5 5.55E-17 0.140226318 3.96E-16 1
0.6 0.136033962 0.140406542 0.968857724 0.332927266
0.7 0.044812666 0.23017148 0.194692522 0.845686182
0.8 -0.42442346 0.395680871 -1.07264083 0.283775935
0.9 -0.61196151 0.240183273 -2.54789396 0.011035123
0.95 -0.14988345 0.22415649 -0.66865539 0.503920256
SMB 0.05 4.12E-02 0.187436443 2.20E-01 0.826073331
0.1 -0.24695992 0.407273313 -0.60637393 0.544449231
0.2 0.111750053 0.262104424 0.426356991 0.669969589
0.3 0.012652539 0.108980265 0.116099356 9.08E-01
0.4 0.008701743 0.086390081 0.100726185 0.919794637
0.5 -4.16E-17 0.089543501 -4.65E-16 1.00E+00
0.6 -0.14492547 0.09315403 -1.55576165 0.120184953
0.7 -0.32493612 0.124116211 -2.61799903 0.009022394
0.8 -0.70624961 0.167973434 -4.20453158 2.93E-05
0.9 -3.85E-01 0.219433998 -1.76E+00 0.079515719
0.95 -0.110077 0.151754795 -0.72536095 0.468455978
HML 0.05 -0.09218041 0.171196464 -0.53844807 0.590426871
0.1 -0.96103486 0.206434541 -4.65539759 3.82E-06
0.2 -0.39520567 0.134448849 -2.93944999 0.003388554
0.3 -0.14588581 0.079529922 -1.8343512 0.066996293
0.4 -0.04220327 0.072147657 -0.58495697 0.558751882
0.5 0 0.0751815 0 1
0.6 -0.00671181 0.086333638 -0.07774275 0.938053343
0.7 -5.60E-02 0.152040507 -3.68E-01 0.712848491
0.8 0.010511483 0.169682893 0.061947805 0.950620834
0.9 0.009111108 0.148240347 0.061461732 0.951007797
0.95 -0.0118025 0.101689729 -0.11606383 0.907632903
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.02839568 0.117118387 0.242452795 0.808495351
0.1 0.016916653 0.429115124 0.039422179 0.96856424
0.2 0.059494853 0.292008954 0.203743248 0.838609192
0.3 0.056401716 0.104086387 0.541874083 0.588065554
0.4 -0.00364132 0.076189873 -0.0477927 0.961894123
178
0.5 1.43E-17 0.075248715 1.90E-16 1
0.6 0.081506146 0.071428926 1.141080374 0.254199242
0.7 0.235383868 0.134130473 1.754887336 0.079685247
0.8 0.563573991 0.232134037 2.427795594 0.015424274
0.9 0.455483654 0.168765621 2.698912563 0.007112584
0.95 0.141218809 0.117696053 1.199860197 0.230571014
Quantile Process Estimates
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: PGI C RM_RF SMB
HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
User-specified process quantiles: 0.05
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.95
Display all coefficients
Quantile Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.
C 0.05 -0.06985843 0.008114059 -8.6095541 2.69E-17
0.1 -0.05269693 0.007383464 -7.13715531 1.79E-12
0.2 -0.03384825 0.0055003 -6.15389204 1.08E-09
0.3 -0.02559253 0.004598353 -5.56558574 3.33E-08
0.4 -0.01869671 0.004271701 -4.3768783 1.33E-05
0.5 -0.01882221 0.004211204 -4.46955607 8.70E-06
0.6 -0.01225811 0.00500669 -2.44834671 0.014516467
0.7 -0.00023494 0.006098933 -0.03852177 0.969279094
0.8 0.008695767 0.006092872 1.427203178 0.153822952
0.9 0.016812029 0.006020499 2.79246426 0.005327188
0.95 0.023515949 0.00577559 4.071609872 5.02E-05
RM_RF 0.05 0.214645867 0.233747075 0.918282579 0.358684885
0.1 0.432025439 0.224604917 1.923490571 5.47E-02
0.2 0.55022032 0.15735404 3.496702841 0.000491034
0.3 0.517425697 0.142960395 3.619363935 0.000309616
0.4 0.541167866 0.134480701 4.024130303 6.14E-05
0.5 0.410131319 0.130951885 3.131923763 0.001785396
0.6 0.482221424 0.153431041 3.142919592 0.001720285
0.7 0.619484174 0.179324421 3.454544399 0.000573564
0.8 0.596595418 0.184087732 3.240821168 0.001229855
179
0.9 0.492465129 0.182845017 2.693347276 0.007188208
0.95 0.36442185 0.186121558 1.957977652 0.050500991
SMB 0.05 0.042996974 0.245378382 0.175227229 0.860935363
0.1 0.18165396 0.228820036 0.793872614 0.427451564
0.2 0.151778456 0.145930045 1.040076811 0.298547116
0.3 0.116615634 0.099274513 1.174678477 0.24039356
0.4 0.076967952 0.07998497 0.962280193 0.336133635
0.5 0.02878464 0.073230988 0.393066397 0.694351387
0.6 -0.0532228 0.086570504 -0.61479143 0.5388276
0.7 -0.02396786 0.108270798 -0.22136955 0.824848366
0.8 0.14576162 0.135618168 1.0747942 0.28271737
0.9 0.152914787 0.179936261 0.849827523 0.39561752
0.95 0.067663404 0.093650593 0.722509082 0.470144761
HML 0.05 -0.11593227 0.219686509 -0.52771686 0.59780898
0.1 -0.15267454 0.137755899 -1.10829768 0.267990752
0.2 0.029158428 0.106556317 0.273643352 0.784413312
0.3 0.018376446 0.073861268 0.248796783 0.803567339
0.4 -0.06354904 0.061949292 -1.02582356 0.305214445
0.5 -0.03011195 0.06486879 -0.46419773 0.642603706
0.6 -0.01585695 0.073559261 -0.21556697 0.829367773
0.7 0.106913067 0.091525096 1.168128432 0.243023967
0.8 0.129376718 0.10140511 1.275840221 0.202298257
0.9 0.057020067 0.135113731 0.422015339 0.673101464
0.95 -0.10546327 0.13211734 -0.79825456 0.424905899
NGANH_TCNH 0.05 0.212790026 0.165503411 1.285713837 0.198830533
0.1 0.146672823 0.183221304 0.800522752 0.423591698
0.2 0.184593493 0.124384615 1.484054065 0.138099039
0.3 0.121359465 0.080388507 1.509661898 0.131434925
0.4 0.038290526 0.071130751 0.53831185 0.590477516
0.5 0.018553074 0.069866431 0.26555062 0.790638202
0.6 0.091329486 0.09038808 1.010415155 0.312532583
0.7 0.110501187 0.117358406 0.941570283 0.3466324
0.8 0.290507463 0.136828394 2.123151894 0.033977927
0.9 0.296702076 0.141889869 2.091073009 0.036764906
0.95 0.149816926 0.114667766 1.306530428 0.191662484
180
PHỤ LỤC 8
KiỂM ĐỊNH SỰ KHÁC NHAU CỦA CÁC HỆ SỐ TRONG MÔ
HÌNH FAMA-FRENCH VỚI HỆ SỐ NGÀNH ỨNG VỚI CÁC
MỨC PHÂN VỊ KHÁC NHAU
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: AGR C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 53.34466378 32 0.010340875
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: CTG C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 68.43961921 32 0.000186989
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: EIB C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
181
Wald Test 77.64555123 32 1.15E-05
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: SSI C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 68.69661203 32 0.000173515
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: STB C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 45.64730844 32 0.055803112
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: VCB C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 49.91252 32 0.0227
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
182
Specification: BID C RM SMB HML TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 58.3679 32 0.003
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: MBB C RM SMB HML TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 99.55092 32 0
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: PGI C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 91.36097 32 0
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: SII C RM_RF SMB HML NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
183
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 186.8105 32 0
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: HCM C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 62.8674 32 0.0009
Quantile Slope Equality Test
Equation: UNTITLED
Specification: OGC C RM_RF SMB HML
NGANH_TCNH
Estimated equation quantile tau = 0.5
Number of test quantiles: 10
Test statistic compares all coefficients
Test Summary Chi-Sq. Statistic Chi-Sq. d.f. Prob.
Wald Test 59.81127 32 0.002
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- phan_tich_dau_tu_chung_khoan_tren_thi_truong_chung_khoan_viet_nam_bang_phuong_phap_thong_ke_phan_vi.pdf