Luận án Vai trò của nhà nước với hoạt động đầu tư trực tiếp ra nước ngoài của Việt Nam trong thời kỳ hội nhập

ào l ĩnh v ực nông- 18 12.9 12.9 37.9 lâm nghi ệp Đầu t ư vào l ĩnh v ực d ịch v ụ 48 34.3 34.3 72.1 Đầu t ư vào đa l ĩnh v ực 24 17.1 17.1 89.3 Không có nhu c ầu đầu t ư ti ếp 15 10.7 10.7 100.0 Total 140 100.0 100.0 Ph ụ lục 14 Các rào c ản khi DN ĐTTTRNN Các rào c ản Tần s ố % % h ợp l ệ % tích l ũy Cơ ch ế chính sách c ủa Vi ệt Nam 39 27.9 27.9 27.9 Thi ếu Chính sách h ỗ tr ợ từ phía nhà n ước Vi ệt 58 41.4 41.4 69.3 Nam Hi ểu bi ết pháp lu ật, tôn giáo, tín ng ưỡng n ước s ở 15 10.7 10.7 80.0 tại Xu ất nh ập kh ẩu máy móc thi ết b ị ph ục v ụ dự án 11 7.9 7.9 87.9 Tuy ển lao động 10 7.1 7.1 95.0 Đă ng ký t ạm trú cho lao động Vi ệt Nam t ại n ước 6 4.3 4.3 99.3 ngoài Khác 1 .7 .7 100.0 Total 140 100.0 100.0 X (Ngu ồn: K ết qu ả kh ảo sát c ủa tác gi ả) Ph ụ lục 15 Đánh giá v ề s ự bình đẳng gi ữa các doanh nghi ệp % tích Đánh giá s ự bình đẳng gi ữa DNNN và DN khác Tần s ố % % h ợp l ệ lũy Không có s ự bình đẳng 14 10.0 10.0 10.0 Ch ưa bình đẳng và c ần ti ếp t ục hoàn thi ện 93 66.4 66.4 76.4 Có s ự bình đẳng 33 23.6 23.6 100.0 Total 140 100.0 100.0 X Ph ụ lục s ố 16 Kết qu ả phân tích ph ươ ng sai (Anova) các y ếu tố cấu thành ĐTRNN theo lo ại DN phân chia doanh nghi ệp theo hình th ức s ở hữu nh ư sau: Doanh nghi ệp thu ộc khu v ực kinh t ế tư nhân (1); Doanh nghi ệp Nhà n ước (2). Descriptives S vn đu t ư qua hàng n ăm đu t ư tr c ti p ra n ưc ngoài Std. 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum 1.00 132 1.4545 .86813 .07556 1.3051 1.6040 1.00 4.00 2.00 8 1.3750 .51755 .18298 .9423 1.8077 1.00 2.00 Total 140 1.4500 .85094 .07192 1.3078 1.5922 1.00 4.00 ANOVA S vn đu t ư qua hàng n ăm đu t ư tr c ti p ra n ưc ngoài Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig. Between Groups .048 1 .048 .065 .798 Within Groups 100.602 138 .729 Total 100.650 139 Ph ụ l ục s ố 17 Hệ s ố tin c ậy Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh l ần 1 Scale Scale Corrected Cronbach’s Cronbach’ N of Mean if Variance Item- Alpha if Các khía c ạnh Item s Alpha Items Item if Item Total Item Deleted Deleted Correlatin Deleted q20_1.1 8.6071 2.068 .643 .782 Vi ệc t ạo hành lang pháp lý 0.818 3 q20_1.2 8.6571 1.651 .690 .736 cho ho ạt độ ng ĐTTTRNN q20_1.3 8.7071 1.806 .694 .726 Vi ệc t ạo l ập, m ở r ộng quan q20_2.1 8.1500 3.510 .560 .789 hệ qu ốc t ế v ề ho ạt độ ng 0.787 3 q20_2.2 8.2500 3.239 .755 .573 ĐTTTRNN q20_2.3 8.2857 3.731 .581 .760 q20_3.1 19.5857 4.849 .426 .356 q20_3.2 19.7571 4.430 .395 .344 Vi ệc đị nh h ướng, điều ti ết q20_3.3 19.6143 5.145 .365 .412 các chính sách v ĩ mô có 0.478 6 q20_3.4 19.8571 5.346 .101 .508 liên quan q20_3.5 19.8143 4.728 .203 .459 q20_3.6 19.9071 5.063 .127 .503 q20_4.1 21.6429 16.044 .515 .701 q20_4.2 21.4071 15.509 .606 .680 q20_4.3 21.3857 15.965 .549 .694 Vi ệc h ỗ tr ợ ho ạt độ ng 0.744 7 q20_4.4 21.4357 15.643 .520 .699 ĐTTTRNN q20_4.5 21.4786 14.985 .608 .677 q20_4.6 21.4357 15.989 .555 .693 q20_4.7 20.8714 21.264 .281 .817 (Ngu ồn: T ổng h ợp t ừ kết qu ả ch ạy mô hình t ừ ph ụ lục 18) Ph ụ lục 18 Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh đánh giá ảnh h ưởng c ủa vai trò nhà nước v ới ho ạt động ĐTTTRNN (l ần 1) RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q20_1.1 q20_1.2 /VARIABLES=q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_1.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /MODEL=ALPHA /MODEL=ALPHA /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE SCALE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Scale: ALL VARIABLES Case Processing Summary Scale: ALL VARIABLES Case Processing Summary N % N % Valid 140 100.0 Valid 140 100.0 Cases Excluded a 0 .0 a Cases Excluded 0 .0 Total 140 100.0 Total 140 100.0 a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. Reliability Statistics Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Cronbach's N of Alpha Alpha Items .478 6 .818 3 Item Statistics Mean Std. N Item Statistics Deviation Mean Std. N q20_3.1 4.1214 .62867 140 Deviation q20_3.2 3.9500 .80756 140 q20_1.1 4.3786 .68349 140 q20_3.3 4.0929 .64481 140 q20_1.2 4.3286 .82621 140 q20_3.4 3.8500 .83040 140 q20_1.3 4.2786 .75929 140 q20_3.5 3.8929 .93452 140 q20_3.6 3.8000 .91510 140 RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q20_2.1 q20_2.2 /VARIABLES=q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_2.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /MODEL=ALPHA /MODEL=ALPHA /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE SCALE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Scale: ALL VARIABLES Scale: ALL VARIABLES Case Processing Summary Case Processing Summary N % N % Valid 140 100.0 Valid 140 100.0 Cases Excluded a 0 a Cases Excluded 0 .0 Total 140 100.0 Total 140 100.0 a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in Reliability Statistics the procedure. Reliability Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Cronbach's Alpha N of Items Alpha .787 3 .744 7 Item Statistics Item Statistics Mean Std. Deviation N Mean Std. Deviation N q20_2.1 4.1929 1.11817 q20_4.1140 3.3000 1.05735 140 q20_2.2 4.0929 1.03114 q20_4.2140 3.5357 1.03473 140 q20_2.3 4.0571 1.03027 q20_4.3140 3.5571 1.02677 140 q20_4.4 3.5071 1.12203 140 q20_4.5 3.4643 1.12148 140 q20_4.6 3.5071 1.01426 140 q20_4.7 4.0714 1.00103 140 Ph ụ l ục s ố 19. Hệ s ố tin c ậy Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh l ần 2 Scale Scale Cronbach’ Corrected Cronbach’ N of Mean if Varianc s Alpha if Các khía c ạnh Item Item-Total s Alpha Items Item e if Item Item Correlation Deleted Deleted Deleted Vi ệc tạo hành q20_1.1 8.6071 2.068 .643 .782 lang pháp lý cho q20_1.2 8.6571 1.651 .690 .736 0.818 3 ho ạt độ ng q20_1.3 8.7071 1.806 .694 .726 ĐTTTRNN Vi ệc t ạo l ập, m ở q20_2.1 8.1500 3.510 .560 .789 rộng quan h ệ q20_2.2 8.2500 3.239 .755 .573 0.787 3 qu ốc t ế v ề ho ạt q20_2.3 8.2857 3.731 .581 .760 động ĐTTTRNN Vi ệc đị nh h ướng, q20_3.1 8.0429 1.610 .580 .673 điều ti ết các q20_3.2 8.2143 1.220 .593 .670 0.751 3 chính sách v ĩ mô q20_3.3 8.0714 1.563 .590 .660 có liên quan q20_4.1 17.5714 15.383 .574 .789 q20_4.2 17.3357 15.016 .646 .774 Vi ệc h ỗ tr ợ ho ạt q20_4.3 17.3143 15.426 .593 .785 0.817 6 động ĐTTTRNN q20_4.4 17.3643 15.168 .553 .794 q20_4.5 17.4071 14.891 .591 .786 q20_4.6 17.3643 15.960 .528 .799 (Ngu ồn: T ổng h ợp t ừ kết qu ả ch ạy mô hình t ừ ph ụ lục 20) Ph ụ lục s ố 20. Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh đánh giá ảnh h ưởng c ủa vai trò nhà nước v ới ho ạt động ĐTTTRNN (l ần 2) RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q20_1.1 q20_1.2 /VARIABLES=q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_1.3 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /MODEL=ALPHA /MODEL=ALPHA /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. SCALE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Scale: ALL VARIABLES Scale: ALL VARIABLES Case Processing Summary Case Processing N % Summary Valid 140 100.0 N % Cases Excluded a 0 .0 Valid 140 100.0 Total 140 100.0 a Cases Excluded 0 .0 a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. Total 140 100.0 Reliability Statistics a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. Cronbach's N of Items Reliability Statistics Alpha Cronbach's N of .751 3 Alpha Items Item Statistics .818 3 Mean Std. N Deviation Item Statistics q20_3.1 4.1214 .62867 140 Mean Std. N q20_3.2 3.9500 .80756 140 Deviation q20_3.3 4.0929 .64481 140 q20_1.1 4.3786 .68349 140 q20_1.2 4.3286 .82621 140 q20_1.3 4.2786 .75929 140 RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 RELIABILITY q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 /VARIABLES=q20_2.1 q20_2.2 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL q20_2.3 /MODEL=ALPHA /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE /MODEL=ALPHA /SUMMARY=TOTAL. /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE Scale: ALL VARIABLES SCALE Case Processing Summary /SUMMARY=TOTAL. N % Scale: ALL VARIABLES Valid 140 100.0 Case Processing Summary Cases Excluded a 0 .0 N % Total 140 100.0 Valid 140 100.0 a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in Cases Excluded a 0 .0 the procedure. Reliability Statistics Total 140 100.0 Cronbach's Alpha N of Items a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. .817 6 Reliability Statistics Item Statistics Cronbach's Alpha N of Mean Std. Deviation N Items q20_4.1 3.3000 1.05735 140 .787 3 q20_4.2 3.5357 1.03473 140 Item Statistics q20_4.3 3.5571 1.02677 140 Mean Std. N q20_4.4 3.5071 1.12203 140 Deviation q20_4.5 3.4643 1.12148 140 q20_2.1 4.1929 1.11817 140 q20_4.6 3.5071 1.01426 140 q20_2.2 4.0929 1.03114 140 q20_2.3 4.0571 1.03027 140 Ph ụ lục số 21 FACTOR /VARIABLES q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 /MISSING LISTWISE /ANALYSIS q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 /PRINT INITIAL KMO INV EXTRACTION ROTATION /FORMAT SORT BLANK(.5) /CRITERIA MINEIGEN(1) ITERATE(25) /EXTRACTION PAF /CRITERIA ITERATE(25) /ROTATION PROMAX(4) /METHOD=CORRELATION. KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of .768 Sampling Adequacy. Approx. Chi- 740.708 Bartlett's Test of Square Sphericity Df 105 Sig. .000 Inverse of Correlation Matrix q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_1.1 1.861 -.587 -.555 -.205 -.071 -.031 .016 -.216 .121 -.182 .121 .000 .216 .087 -.269 q20_1.2 -.587 2.118 -.897 -.219 -.013 -.147 -.082 .313 -.039 .005 -.121 .349 -.015 -.243 -.032 q20_1.3 -.555 -.897 2.152 -.081 -.203 -.179 .103 -.340 -.011 .117 -.045 -.076 -.097 .014 .168 q20_2.1 -.205 -.219 -.081 1.862 -.958 .016 -.088 -.072 .104 .178 -.130 .095 .066 .020 .204 q20_2.2 -.071 -.013 -.203 -.958 2.463 -1.091 .076 .044 .096 .090 -.094 -.091 -.007 -.056 -.064 q20_2.3 -.031 -.147 -.179 .016 -1.091 1.900 .045 .105 -.253 .038 .230 -.255 -.061 .049 -.156 q20_3.1 .016 -.082 .103 -.088 .076 .045 1.552 -.514 -.545 .040 -.139 .095 .012 -.132 -.003 q20_3.2 -.216 .313 -.340 -.072 .044 .105 -.514 1.695 -.615 .035 -.064 .063 .142 -.086 -.151 q20_3.3 .121 -.039 -.011 .104 .096 -.253 -.545 -.615 1.736 -.249 .321 .116 -.090 .176 .044 q20_4.1 -.182 .005 .117 .178 .090 .038 .040 .035 -.249 1.693 -.620 .012 -.258 -.442 -.038 q20_4.2 .121 -.121 -.045 -.130 -.094 .230 -.139 -.064 .321 -.620 2.185 -1.031 -.019 -.061 -.266 q20_4.3 .000 .349 -.076 .095 -.091 -.255 .095 .063 .116 .012 -1.031 2.006 -.230 -.299 -.029 q20_4.4 .216 -.015 -.097 .066 -.007 -.061 .012 .142 -.090 -.258 -.019 -.230 1.546 -.230 -.461 q20_4.5 .087 -.243 .014 .020 -.056 .049 -.132 -.086 .176 -.442 -.061 -.299 -.230 1.619 -.270 q20_4.6 -.269 -.032 .168 .204 -.064 -.156 -.003 -.151 .044 -.038 -.266 -.029 -.461 -.270 1.532 Communalities Initial Extraction q20_1.1 .463 .547 q20_1.2 .528 .658 q20_1.3 .535 .626 q20_2.1 .463 .457 q20_2.2 .594 .942 q20_2.3 .474 .460 q20_3.1 .356 .471 q20_3.2 .410 .524 q20_3.3 .424 .568 q20_4.1 .410 .459 q20_4.2 .542 .551 q20_4.3 .501 .523 q20_4.4 .353 .376 q20_4.5 .382 .450 q20_4.6 .347 .360 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Rotation Sums of Loadings Squared Loadings a Total % of Cumulativ Total % of Cumulati Total Variance e % Varian ve % ce 1 3.406 22.708 22.708 3.016 20.108 20.108 2.668 2 3.189 21.257 43.965 2.681 17.871 37.979 2.568 3 2.062 13.748 57.713 1.583 10.554 48.533 2.437 4 1.038 6.917 64.630 .693 4.618 53.151 1.676 5 .838 5.585 70.215 6 .646 4.306 74.521 7 .611 4.074 78.596 8 .556 3.710 82.305 9 .527 3.516 85.821 10 .496 3.304 89.126 11 .401 2.673 91.799 12 .384 2.559 94.357 13 .306 2.039 96.396 14 .278 1.856 98.252 15 .262 1.748 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Factor Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q20_2.2 .767 q20_1.3 .729 q20_1.2 .703 q20_1.1 .655 q20_2.1 .653 q20_2.3 .583 q20_4.2 .719 q20_4.3 .688 q20_4.5 .637 q20_4.1 .575 q20_4.4 .573 q20_4.6 .567 q20_3.2 .688 q20_3.3 .676 q20_3.1 .663 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. Attempted to extract 4 factors. More than 25 iterations required. (Convergence=,001). Extraction was terminated. Pattern Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q20_4.2 .726 q20_4.5 .674 q20_4.1 .669 q20_4.3 .664 q20_4.4 .610 q20_4.6 .603 q20_1.2 .827 q20_1.3 .731 q20_1.1 .730 q20_2.2 .999 q20_2.3 .630 q20_2.1 .504 q20_3.3 .752 q20_3.2 .716 q20_3.1 .695 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization.a a. Rotation converged in 5 iterations. Structure Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 q20_4.2 .737 q20_4.3 .691 q20_4.5 .663 q20_4.1 .653 q20_4.4 .611 q20_4.6 .588 q20_1.2 .807 q20_1.3 .787 q20_1.1 .739 q20_2.2 .969 q20_2.3 .670 q20_2.1 .512 .630 q20_3.3 .747 q20_3.2 .719 q20_3.1 .682 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. Factor Correlation Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 1 1.000 -.062 .006 -.133 2 -.062 1.000 .545 .132 3 .006 .545 1.000 -.085 4 -.133 .132 -.085 1.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. Ph ụ lục s ố 22. Kết qu ả mean Q20 q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 * q20a q20a q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 1.00 Mean 3.0000 3.0000 4.0000 2.5000 2.5000 2.5000 2.0000 2.5000 3.5000 2.5000 4.0000 3.0000 4.0000 4.5000 4.0000 3.0000 3.5000 4.5000 5.0000 Std. Deviation 1.41421 1.41421 .00000 .70711 .70711 .70711 .00000 .70711 .70711 .70711 1.41421 1.41421 .00000 .70711 .00000 1.41421 .70711 .70711 .00000 2.00 Mean 4.0400 3.8400 4.0400 3.0800 3.4000 3.4000 3.5600 3.7600 3.6000 3.6800 3.7200 3.4400 4.2000 4.1200 4.0000 3.8000 3.9600 3.8400 3.4800 Std. Deviation .61101 .80000 .61101 1.07703 .86603 1.08012 1.19304 1.09087 1.11803 1.02956 1.20830 .96090 .76376 1.01325 .91287 1.32288 1.01980 1.10604 1.19443 3.00 Mean 4.2903 4.0645 4.2258 3.4516 3.5484 3.7419 3.3548 3.5806 3.6774 3.4516 3.6774 3.5484 4.4516 4.4839 4.3548 4.4839 4.3226 4.2903 4.3548 Std. Deviation .52874 .85383 .61696 1.31247 1.17866 1.09446 .98483 1.14816 1.07663 1.20661 1.22167 1.15004 .76762 .96163 .75491 .72438 .94471 .90161 .91464 4.00 Mean 4.1026 3.9872 4.0641 3.2821 3.4231 3.5128 3.2179 3.4487 3.4615 3.5000 3.2949 3.5256 4.4231 4.3462 4.3590 4.2949 4.1026 4.0769 4.1667 Std. Deviation .63634 .76436 .67111 1.27816 1.07533 1.06593 1.04007 .94865 .98945 1.13675 1.05817 1.00291 .61410 .66111 .70203 1.03333 1.00116 1.01635 .90334 5.00 Mean 4.2500 3.5000 4.0000 3.2500 3.0000 3.5000 3.5000 4.0000 4.2500 3.5000 3.2500 3.5000 4.2500 4.0000 4.0000 3.0000 3.2500 3.0000 3.2500 Std. Deviation .50000 1.00000 .81650 2.06155 1.82574 1.29099 1.00000 1.41421 .95743 1.00000 .50000 .57735 .95743 1.41421 .81650 2.30940 2.06155 1.41421 .50000 Total Mean 4.1214 3.9500 4.0929 3.2714 3.4214 3.5286 3.3000 3.5357 3.5571 3.5071 3.4643 3.5071 4.3786 4.3286 4.2786 4.1929 4.0929 4.0571 4.0714 Std. Deviation .62867 .80756 .64481 1.26288 1.08002 1.07585 1.05735 1.03473 1.02677 1.12203 1.12148 1.01426 .68349 .82621 .75929 1.11817 1.03114 1.03027 1.00103 q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 * q20b q20b q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 2.00 Mean 3.7500 3.8750 4.3750 3.0000 3.2500 3.5000 2.5000 3.2500 3.3750 3.6250 3.1250 3.3750 4.0000 4.3750 4.0000 3.8750 4.0000 4.1250 3.7500 Std. Deviation 1.03510 .99103 .51755 .92582 1.16496 .75593 .53452 1.28174 1.18773 1.06066 .83452 .51755 .75593 .74402 .75593 1.55265 .75593 .83452 1.28174 3.00 Mean 4.2381 4.0000 4.1429 3.4286 3.6667 3.8095 3.6190 3.9524 3.8571 3.7619 3.7619 3.3333 4.2381 4.2381 4.1905 4.0952 4.0952 4.0952 3.9048 Std. Deviation .43644 .70711 .57321 1.28730 1.11056 1.12335 1.11697 1.11697 .96362 1.13599 1.22085 1.06458 .76842 1.04426 1.03049 1.09109 1.13599 1.17918 .99523 4.00 Mean 4.0800 3.9300 4.0300 3.2200 3.3800 3.4300 3.2800 3.4900 3.5200 3.4900 3.4400 3.5500 4.4200 4.3400 4.3100 4.2500 4.1000 4.0600 4.1300 Std. Deviation .61431 .81965 .65836 1.24381 1.04234 1.08484 1.04524 .97954 1.00985 1.12362 1.11301 1.02863 .65412 .78135 .66203 1.02863 .98985 1.00323 .99143 5.00 Mean 4.5455 4.0909 4.3636 3.6364 3.4545 3.9091 3.4545 3.3636 3.4545 3.0909 3.3636 3.5455 4.5455 4.3636 4.3636 4.0909 4.0909 3.9091 4.0909 Std. Deviation .52223 .83121 .67420 1.62928 1.36848 1.04447 1.12815 1.12006 1.21356 1.13618 1.20605 1.12815 .68755 .92442 1.02691 1.64040 1.44600 1.22103 .94388 Total Mean 4.1214 3.9500 4.0929 3.2714 3.4214 3.5286 3.3000 3.5357 3.5571 3.5071 3.4643 3.5071 4.3786 4.3286 4.2786 4.1929 4.0929 4.0571 4.0714 Std. Deviation .62867 .80756 .64481 1.26288 1.08002 1.07585 1.05735 1.03473 1.02677 1.12203 1.12148 1.01426 .68349 .82621 .75929 1.11817 1.03114 1.03027 1.00103 q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 * q20c q20c q20_1.1 q20_1.2 q20_1.3 q20_2.1 q20_2.2 q20_2.3 q20_3.1 q20_3.2 q20_3.3 q20_3.4 q20_3.5 q20_3.6 q20_4.1 q20_4.2 q20_4.3 q20_4.4 q20_4.5 q20_4.6 q20_4.7 1.00 Mean 4.3333 3.6667 4.0000 3.0000 3.3333 3.3333 4.6667 4.6667 3.6667 3.6667 5.0000 3.6667 3.6667 3.3333 3.0000 3.3333 3.6667 3.6667 3.6667 Std. Deviation .57735 .57735 .00000 1.73205 .57735 1.15470 .57735 .57735 .57735 .57735 .00000 .57735 1.15470 2.08167 2.00000 1.52753 1.52753 1.15470 1.15470 2.00 Mean 4.0854 3.9268 4.0976 3.2561 3.4878 3.5610 3.2439 3.5854 3.6098 3.6220 3.3659 3.5976 4.3902 4.2927 4.2927 4.1220 4.0976 4.0976 4.0488 Std. Deviation .65171 .78222 .62083 1.26502 .99683 1.00735 1.00075 .95518 .99077 1.09590 1.07166 1.07565 .64322 .80871 .74515 1.16947 .98895 1.06121 1.07614 3.00 Mean 4.2414 3.9310 4.2759 3.4483 3.5517 3.7586 3.3448 3.3103 3.4828 3.1724 3.6897 3.3448 4.3793 4.5862 4.3793 4.3793 4.1379 4.2414 4.2759 Std. Deviation .63556 .92316 .64899 1.21262 1.21262 1.05746 1.20344 1.16813 1.12188 1.25553 1.25651 1.04457 .72771 .62776 .67685 .94165 1.09297 .91242 .88223 4.00 Mean 4.0455 4.0455 3.8182 3.4091 3.2727 3.3182 3.2273 3.5455 3.3636 3.5000 3.1818 3.3636 4.4545 4.2273 4.2273 4.4545 4.1818 3.8636 4.0000 Std. Deviation .57547 .78542 .73266 1.14056 1.07711 1.24924 1.10978 1.14340 1.09307 1.10195 1.00647 .72673 .67098 .81251 .61193 .91168 1.09702 1.03719 .92582 5.00 Mean 4.2500 4.2500 4.2500 1.7500 2.0000 2.5000 3.5000 3.2500 4.0000 3.5000 4.2500 3.5000 4.2500 4.5000 4.5000 3.5000 3.5000 3.2500 3.7500 Std. Deviation .50000 .95743 .50000 1.50000 1.41421 1.29099 .57735 .95743 1.15470 1.00000 .95743 1.29099 .95743 1.00000 .57735 1.73205 1.00000 .95743 .50000 Total Mean 4.1214 3.9500 4.0929 3.2714 3.4214 3.5286 3.3000 3.5357 3.5571 3.5071 3.4643 3.5071 4.3786 4.3286 4.2786 4.1929 4.0929 4.0571 4.0714 Std. Deviation .62867 .80756 .64481 1.26288 1.08002 1.07585 1.05735 1.03473 1.02677 1.12203 1.12148 1.01426 .68349 .82621 .75929 1.11817 1.03114 1.03027 1.00103 Ph ụ lục số 23 Hệ s ố tin c ậy Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh đánh giá m ức độ tác độ ng của các vai trò nhà n ước v ới ĐTTTRNN Scale Cronbach's Scale Mean Corrected Cronbach's N of Variance Alpha if Các khía c ạnh Item if Item Item-Total Alpha Items if Item Item Deleted Correlation Deleted Deleted Vi ệc t ạo hành lang q21_1.1 7.0857 3.101 .881 .824 pháp lý cho ho ạt 0.911 3 q21_1.2 6.8929 3.809 .787 .902 động ĐTTTRNN q21_1.3 6.8929 3.693 .810 .884 Vi ệc t ạo l ập, m ở q21_2.1 8.5143 3.460 .625 .914 rộng quan h ệ qu ốc 0.866 3 q21_2.2 8.3857 2.901 .791 .766 tế v ề ĐTTTRNN q21_2.3 8.3143 2.908 .826 .734 q21_3.1 19.8357 7.663 .293 .611 Vi ệc đị nh h ướng, q21_3.2 20.0429 7.005 .414 .569 điều ti ết các chính q21_3.3 19.8571 6.627 .425 .561 0.63 6 sách v ĩ mô có liên q21_3.4 20.1500 6.172 .515 .520 quan q21_3.5 20.5357 7.330 .253 .629 q21_3.6 20.5786 7.066 .286 .618 q21_4.1 20.8429 21.270 .680 .862 q21_4.2 20.7714 20.926 .725 .856 q21_4.3 20.5786 21.771 .752 .853 Vi ệc h ỗ tr ợ ho ạt 0.881 7 q21_4.4 20.7429 23.444 .619 .870 động ĐTTTRNN q21_4.5 20.5643 21.816 .699 .859 q21_4.6 20.6000 22.659 .598 .872 q21_4.7 20.5429 22.955 .600 .871 (Ngu ồn: T ổng h ợp t ừ k ết qu ả ch ạy mô hình t ừ ph ụ l ục 23) Ph ụ lục s ố 24. Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh đánh giá m ức độ tác động c ủa vai trò nhà n ước v ới ho ạt động ĐTTTRNN (l ần 1) RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 /VARIABLES=q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_1.3 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') /MODEL=ALPHA ALL /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE /MODEL=ALPHA /SUMMARY=TOTAL. /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE Scale: ALL VARIABLES /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Case Processing Summary N % Scale: ALL VARIABLES Valid 140 100.0 Case Processing Summary Cases Excluded a 0 .0 N % Total 140 100.0 Valid 140 100.0 a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the Cases Excluded a 0 .0 procedure. Reliability Statistics Total 140 100.0 Cronbach's N of Items a. Listwise deletion based on all variables in the procedure. Alpha .630 6 Reliability Statistics Item Statistics Cronbach's N of Items Alpha Mean Std. N .911 3 Deviation q21_3.1 4.3643 .72182 Item Statistics q21_3.2 4.1571 .78906 Mean Std. q21_3.3 4.3429 .88774 Deviation q21_3.4 4.0500 .91608 q21_1.1 3.3500 1.07907 140q21_3.5 3.6643 .89451 q21_1.2 3.5429 .94733 140q21_3.6 3.6214 .93276 q21_1.3 3.5429 .96240 140 RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q21_2.1 q21_2.2 /VARIABLES=q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_2.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL ALL /MODEL=ALPHA /MODEL=ALPHA /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. SCALE Scale: ALL VARIABLES /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Case Processing Summary Scale: ALL VARIABLES N % Case Processing Summary Valid 140 100.0 Cases N % Excluded a 0 .0 Valid 140 100.0 Total 140 100.0 Cases Excluded a 0 .0 a. Listwise deletion based on all Total 140 100.0 variables in the procedure. a. Listwise deletion based on all Reliability Statistics variables in the procedure. Cronbach's N of Items Alpha Reliability Statistics .881 7 Cronbach's N of Items Item Statistics Alpha Mean Std. N .866 3 Deviation q21_4.1 3.2643 1.11633 140 Item Statistics q21_4.2 3.3357 1.10987 140 Mean Std. q21_4.3 3.5286 .97037 140 Deviation q21_4.4 3.3643 .88318 140 q21_2.1 4.0929 .93606 140q21_4.5 3.5429 1.02045 140 q21_2.2 4.2214 .98235 140q21_4.6 3.5071 1.02133 140 q21_2.3 4.2929 .95583 140q21_4.7 3.5643 .97605 140 Ph ụ lục số 25. Hệ s ố tin c ậy Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh l ần 2 Scale Scale Corrected Cronbach' N of Cronbach' Mean if Variance if Item-Total s Alpha if Các khía cạnh Item Item s Alpha Item Item Correlatio Item s Deleted Deleted n Deleted Vi ệc t ạo hành lang q21_1.1 7.0857 3.101 .881 .824 pháp lý cho ho ạt 0.911 3 q21_1.2 6.8929 3.809 .787 .902 động ĐTTTRNN q21_1.3 6.8929 3.693 .810 .884 Vi ệc t ạo l ập, m ở q21_2.1 8.5143 3.460 .625 .914 rộng quan h ệ qu ốc 0.866 3 q21_2.2 8.3857 2.901 .791 .766 tế v ề ĐTTTRNN q21_2.3 8.3143 2.908 .826 .734 Vi ệc đị nh h ướng, q21_3.2 8.3929 2.571 .571 .734 điều ti ết các chính q21_3.3 8.2071 2.266 .592 .710 0.772 3 sách v ĩ mô liên q21_3.4 8.5000 2.050 .666 .624 quan q21_4.1 20.8429 21.270 .680 .862 q21_4.2 20.7714 20.926 .725 .856 q21_4.3 20.5786 21.771 .752 .853 Vi ệc h ỗ tr ợ ho ạt 0.881 7 q21_4.4 20.7429 23.444 .619 .870 động ĐTTTRNN q21_4.5 20.5643 21.816 .699 .859 q21_4.6 20.6000 22.659 .598 .872 q21_4.7 20.5429 22.955 .600 .871 (Ngu ồn: T ổng h ợp t ừ kết qu ả ch ạy mô hình t ừ ph ụ lục 26) Ph ụ lục s ố 25 Cronbach Alpha thang đo các khía c ạnh đánh giá m ức độ tác động c ủa vai trò nhà n ước v ới ho ạt động ĐTTTRNN (l ần 2) RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 /VARIABLES=q21_1.1 q21_1.2 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL q21_1.3 /MODEL=ALPHA /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE ALL /SUMMARY=TOTAL. /MODEL=ALPHA Scale: ALL VARIABLES /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE Case Processing Summary SCALE N % /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Valid 140 100.0 Scale: ALL VARIABLES Cases Excluded a 0 .0 Case Processing Summary Total 140 100.0 N % a. Listwise deletion based on all Valid 140 100.0 variables in the procedure. a Cases Excluded 0 .0 Reliability Statistics Total 140 100.0 Cronbach's N of Items a. Listwise deletion based on all Alpha variables in the procedure. .772 3 Item Statistics Reliability Statistics Mean Std. N Cronbach's N of Items Deviation Alpha q21_3.2 4.1571 .78906 140 .911 3 q21_3.3 4.3429 .88774 140 q21_3.4 4.0500 .91608 140 Item Statistics Mean Std. Deviation q21_1.1 3.3500 1.07907 140 q21_1.2 3.5429 .94733 140 q21_1.3 3.5429 .96240 140 RELIABILITY RELIABILITY /VARIABLES=q21_2.1 q21_2.2 /VARIABLES=q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_2.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') /SCALE('ALL VARIABLES') ALL ALL /MODEL=ALPHA /MODEL=ALPHA /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE SCALE /STATISTICS=DESCRIPTIVE /SUMMARY=TOTAL. SCALE Scale: ALL VARIABLES /SUMMARY=TOTAL. Case Processing Summary Scale: ALL VARIABLES N % Case Processing Summary Valid 140 100.0 N % Cases Excluded a 0 .0 Cases Valid 140 100.0 Total 140 100.0 Excluded a 0 .0 a. Listwise deletion based on all Total 140 100.0 variables in the procedure. a. Listwise deletion based on all Reliability Statistics variables in the procedure. Cronbach's N of Items Alpha Reliability Statistics .881 7 Cronbach's N of Items Item Statistics Alpha Mean Std. N .866 3 Deviation q21_4.1 3.2643 1.11633 140 Item Statistics q21_4.2 3.3357 1.10987 140 Mean Std. q21_4.3 3.5286 .97037 140 Deviation q21_4.4 3.3643 .88318 140 q21_2.1 4.0929 .93606 140q21_4.5 3.5429 1.02045 140 q21_2.2 4.2214 .98235 140q21_4.6 3.5071 1.02133 140 q21_2.3 4.2929 .95583 140q21_4.7 3.5643 .97605 140 Ph ụ lục số 27. FACTOR /VARIABLES q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 /MISSING LISTWISE /ANALYSIS q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 /PRINT INITIAL KMO INV EXTRACTION ROTATION /FORMAT SORT BLANK(.5) /CRITERIA MINEIGEN(1) ITERATE(25) /EXTRACTION PAF /CRITERIA ITERATE(25) /ROTATION PROMAX(4) /METHOD=CORRELATION. KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of .788 Sampling Adequacy. Approx. Chi- 1284.428 Bartlett's Test of Square Sphericity Df 120 Sig. .000 Inverse of Correlation Matrix q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 q21_1.1 4.981 -1.800 -2.784 .091 -.012 -.007 -.162 -.271 .240 -.231 -.018 -.515 .352 .599 -.497 .127 q21_1.2 -1.800 3.305 -.673 .193 -.102 .382 -.029 -.221 .009 -.513 .021 .180 .090 .030 -.379 -.193 q21_1.3 -2.784 -.673 3.888 -.045 -.235 -.305 .116 .391 -.086 .597 -.089 .268 -.414 -.600 .213 .026 q21_2.1 .091 .193 -.045 1.981 -.465 -.683 -.309 -.027 -.330 .104 -.220 .049 .009 .099 .072 -.386 q21_2.2 -.012 -.102 -.235 -.465 3.768 -2.889 .335 -.237 .064 -.030 -.040 .262 .004 .158 .183 -.060 q21_2.3 -.007 .382 -.305 -.683 -2.889 4.005 -.326 .210 -.035 .094 -.070 -.222 .186 -.187 -.012 .111 q21_3.2 -.162 -.029 .116 -.309 .335 -.326 1.659 -.304 -.594 -.078 .270 -.012 -.085 -.084 .088 .155 q21_3.3 -.271 -.221 .391 -.027 -.237 .210 -.304 1.824 -.863 .403 -.049 -.342 -.216 .247 .353 -.204 q21_3.4 .240 .009 -.086 -.330 .064 -.035 -.594 -.863 2.001 -.181 .145 -.027 .020 -.217 -.385 .412 q21_4.1 -.231 -.513 .597 .104 -.030 .094 -.078 .403 -.181 3.213 -1.931 -.303 .292 -.740 .427 -.383 q21_4.2 -.018 .021 -.089 -.220 -.040 -.070 .270 -.049 .145 -1.931 3.263 -.690 -.336 -.187 -.361 .424 q21_4.3 -.515 .180 .268 .049 .262 -.222 -.012 -.342 -.027 -.303 -.690 2.558 -.535 -.409 -.299 -.279 q21_4.4 .352 .090 -.414 .009 .004 .186 -.085 -.216 .020 .292 -.336 -.535 1.935 -.543 -.164 -.316 q21_4.5 .599 .030 -.600 .099 .158 -.187 -.084 .247 -.217 -.740 -.187 -.409 -.543 2.300 -.084 -.187 q21_4.6 -.497 -.379 .213 .072 .183 -.012 .088 .353 -.385 .427 -.361 -.299 -.164 -.084 2.412 -1.128 q21_4.7 .127 -.193 .026 -.386 -.060 .111 .155 -.204 .412 -.383 .424 -.279 -.316 -.187 -1.128 2.204 Communalities Initial Extraction q21_1.1 .799 .909 q21_1.2 .697 .733 q21_1.3 .743 .732 q21_2.1 .495 .517 q21_2.2 .735 .804 q21_2.3 .750 .882 q21_3.2 .397 .461 q21_3.3 .452 .513 q21_3.4 .500 .655 q21_4.1 .689 .590 q21_4.2 .694 .658 q21_4.3 .609 .673 q21_4.4 .483 .460 q21_4.5 .565 .587 q21_4.6 .585 .490 q21_4.7 .546 .406 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Total Variance Explained Rotation Extraction Sums of Squared Sums of Initial Eigenvalues Loadings Squared Factor a Loadings % of Cumulativ % of Cumulativ Total Total Total Variance e % Variance e % 1 4.956 30.973 30.973 4.578 28.611 28.611 4.111 2 2.815 17.593 48.566 2.492 15.575 44.186 3.197 3 2.027 12.669 61.234 1.745 10.906 55.093 2.406 4 1.591 9.941 71.176 1.256 7.848 62.941 1.962 5 .931 5.817 76.992 6 .612 3.828 80.820 7 .580 3.627 84.447 8 .440 2.747 87.194 9 .398 2.487 89.681 10 .380 2.378 92.059 11 .329 2.057 94.116 12 .265 1.658 95.774 13 .234 1.461 97.235 14 .172 1.077 98.312 15 .144 .901 99.214 16 .126 .786 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Factor Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.3 .733 q21_4.2 .717 q21_4.6 .696 q21_4.1 .679 q21_1.2 .675 q21_4.5 .663 q21_1.1 .643 -.624 q21_4.7 .627 q21_4.4 .593 q21_2.3 .796 q21_2.2 .734 q21_2.1 .678 q21_3.4 .536 q21_3.2 q21_1.3 .562 -.584 q21_3.3 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. 4 factors extracted. 11 iterations required. Pattern Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.2 .831 q21_4.3 .804 q21_4.5 .801 q21_4.1 .785 q21_4.4 .657 q21_4.7 .542 q21_4.6 q21_1.1 .978 q21_1.3 .854 q21_1.2 .813 q21_2.3 .949 q21_2.2 .903 q21_2.1 .617 q21_3.4 .797 q21_3.3 .729 q21_3.2 .648 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization.a a. Rotation converged in 6 iterations. Structure Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.3 .811 q21_4.2 .799 q21_4.5 .761 q21_4.1 .754 q21_4.4 .662 q21_4.6 .631 .522 q21_4.7 .616 q21_1.1 .952 q21_1.2 .846 q21_1.3 .843 q21_2.3 .938 q21_2.2 .890 q21_2.1 .673 q21_3.4 .806 q21_3.3 .713 q21_3.2 .672 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. Factor Correlation Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 1 1.000 .413 -.150 -.046 2 .413 1.000 -.051 -.113 3 -.150 -.051 1.000 .270 4 -.046 -.113 .270 1.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. FACTOR /VARIABLES q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.7 /MISSING LISTWISE /ANALYSIS q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.7 /PRINT INITIAL KMO INV EXTRACTION ROTATION /FORMAT SORT BLANK(.5) /CRITERIA MINEIGEN(1) ITERATE(25) /EXTRACTION PAF /CRITERIA ITERATE(25) /ROTATION PROMAX(4) /METHOD=CORRELATION. Inverse of Correlation Matrix q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.7 q21_1.1 4.879 -1.879 -2.740 .106 .026 -.009 -.143 -.199 .161 -.143 -.092 -.577 .318 .582 -.106 q21_1.2 -1.879 3.245 -.640 .204 -.074 .380 -.016 -.166 -.051 -.446 -.036 .133 .064 .017 -.370 q21_1.3 -2.740 -.640 3.869 -.051 -.251 -.304 .108 .360 -.052 .560 -.057 .295 -.400 -.593 .126 q21_2.1 .106 .204 -.051 1.979 -.470 -.682 -.311 -.038 -.319 .091 -.209 .057 .014 .102 -.352 q21_2.2 .026 -.074 -.251 -.470 3.754 -2.888 .328 -.264 .093 -.062 -.012 .284 .016 .164 .025 q21_2.3 -.009 .380 -.304 -.682 -2.888 4.005 -.325 .212 -.037 .096 -.072 -.223 .185 -.187 .106 q21_3.2 -.143 -.016 .108 -.311 .328 -.325 1.656 -.317 -.580 -.094 .283 -.002 -.079 -.081 .196 q21_3.3 -.199 -.166 .360 -.038 -.264 .212 -.317 1.773 -.806 .341 .003 -.298 -.192 .260 -.039 q21_3.4 .161 -.051 -.052 -.319 .093 -.037 -.580 -.806 1.940 -.113 .087 -.075 -.007 -.230 .231 q21_4.1 -.143 -.446 .560 .091 -.062 .096 -.094 .341 -.113 3.137 -1.867 -.250 .321 -.725 -.184 q21_4.2 -.092 -.036 -.057 -.209 -.012 -.072 .283 .003 .087 -1.867 3.209 -.735 -.361 -.200 .256 q21_4.3 -.577 .133 .295 .057 .284 -.223 -.002 -.298 -.075 -.250 -.735 2.521 -.556 -.420 -.419 q21_4.4 .318 .064 -.400 .014 .016 .185 -.079 -.192 -.007 .321 -.361 -.556 1.923 -.548 -.393 q21_4.5 .582 .017 -.593 .102 .164 -.187 -.081 .260 -.230 -.725 -.200 -.420 -.548 2.297 -.227 q21_4.7 -.106 -.370 .126 -.352 .025 .106 .196 -.039 .231 -.184 .256 -.419 -.393 -.227 1.676 KMO and Bartlett's Test (L ần 2) Kaiser -Meyer -Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .778 Approx. Chi -Square 1170.412 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Df 105 Sig. .000 Communalities Initial Extraction q21_1.1 .795 .922 q21_1.2 .692 .726 q21_1.3 .742 .748 q21_2.1 .495 .520 q21_2.2 .734 .802 q21_2.3 .750 .884 q21_3.2 .396 .461 q21_3.3 .436 .513 q21_3.4 .484 .656 q21_4.1 .681 .624 q21_4.2 .688 .683 q21_4.3 .603 .668 q21_4.4 .480 .447 q21_4.5 .565 .597 q21_4.7 .403 .347 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Total Variance Explained Rotation Sums of Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Squared Factor Loadings a % of Cumulative % of Cumulative Total Total Total Variance % Variance % 1 4.456 29.709 29.709 4.100 27.334 27.334 3.663 2 2.813 18.753 48.462 2.492 16.611 43.945 2.886 3 2.026 13.507 61.969 1.752 11.683 55.627 2.362 4 1.582 10.545 72.514 1.254 8.360 63.987 1.962 5 .818 5.455 77.968 6 .590 3.935 81.903 7 .554 3.691 85.594 8 .425 2.831 88.425 9 .396 2.639 91.064 10 .335 2.236 93.300 11 .313 2.089 95.388 12 .234 1.559 96.947 13 .185 1.232 98.178 14 .144 .963 99.142 15 .129 .858 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Factor Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.2 .736 q21_4.3 .728 q21_4.1 .706 q21_4.5 .672 q21_1.2 .668 q21_1.1 .642 -.629 q21_4.4 .582 q21_4.7 .578 q21_2.3 .795 q21_2.2 .732 q21_2.1 .675 q21_3.4 .532 q21_3.2 q21_1.3 .565 -.589 q21_3.3 .501 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. 4 factors extracted. 11 iterations required. Pattern Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.2 .831 q21_4.5 .794 q21_4.1 .792 q21_4.3 .789 q21_4.4 .640 q21_4.7 .503 q21_1.1 .975 q21_1.3 .855 q21_1.2 .806 q21_2.3 .949 q21_2.2 .901 q21_2.1 .619 q21_3.4 .798 q21_3.3 .730 q21_3.2 .650 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization.a a. Rotation converged in 6 iterations. Structure Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 q21_4.2 .817 q21_4.3 .807 q21_4.1 .779 q21_4.5 .771 q21_4.4 .652 q21_4.7 .566 q21_1.1 .959 q21_1.3 .855 q21_1.2 .839 q21_2.3 .939 q21_2.2 .890 q21_2.1 .675 q21_3.4 .807 q21_3.3 .713 q21_3.2 .673 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. Factor Correlation Matrix Factor 1 2 3 4 1 1.000 .369 -.124 -.046 2 .369 1.000 -.020 -.115 3 -.124 -.020 1.000 .272 4 -.046 -.115 .272 1.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. Ph ụ lục s ố 28. Kết qu ả mean Q21 q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 * q21a q21a q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 1.00 Mean 3.0000 3.0000 3.5000 4.5000 4.5000 4.5000 4.0000 4.0000 4.5000 4.0000 3.5000 3.5000 4.0000 4.5000 4.0000 3.5000 3.5000 3.5000 3.5000 Std. Deviation .00000 .00000 .70711 .70711 .70711 .70711 .00000 .00000 .70711 .00000 .70711 .70711 1.41421 .70711 .00000 .70711 2.12132 .70711 .70711 2.00 Mean 2.9667 3.2333 3.2667 4.3333 4.4000 4.4000 4.5333 4.2667 4.6667 4.3667 3.6333 3.6000 2.9000 2.8333 3.4667 3.2333 3.3667 3.1333 3.3000 Std. Deviation 1.21721 1.13512 1.04826 .88409 1.06997 1.06997 .68145 .82768 .80230 .61495 .88992 .96847 1.09387 .98553 1.04166 .81720 1.03335 1.25212 1.26355 3.00 Mean 3.4407 3.5932 3.4576 4.0169 4.1356 4.1695 4.3898 4.1356 4.2542 3.8983 3.5424 3.5085 3.3559 3.4915 3.4576 3.2712 3.4915 3.5593 3.5593 Std. Deviation 1.00466 .85336 .95271 .93756 .91835 .93131 .61636 .86018 .88265 1.02881 .89678 .98913 1.17095 1.13522 .97064 .88728 1.08870 .95179 .98735 4.00 Mean 3.5556 3.7500 3.8611 4.0278 4.2500 4.3889 4.2778 4.1389 4.3611 3.9722 4.0000 3.8611 3.5000 3.5556 3.7222 3.6389 3.8333 3.8056 3.8333 Std. Deviation 1.02663 .93732 .93052 .90982 1.02470 .87105 .74108 .54263 .86694 .84468 .82808 .86694 .94112 1.08086 .97427 1.01848 .87831 .88864 .77460 5.00 Mean 3.3077 3.5385 3.6923 4.0000 4.0769 4.3077 4.1538 4.0769 3.9231 4.2308 3.3846 3.5385 2.9231 3.0000 3.3846 3.3077 3.3846 3.3077 3.4615 Std. Deviation 1.18213 .87706 .75107 1.15470 1.03775 1.10940 1.14354 1.03775 1.03775 1.09193 .96077 .77625 1.18754 1.00000 .86972 .48038 .86972 .94733 .51887 Total Mean 3.3500 3.5429 3.5429 4.0929 4.2214 4.2929 3.3643 3.1571 3.3429 3.0500 3.6643 3.6214 3.2643 3.3357 3.5286 3.3643 3.5429 3.5071 3.5643 Std. Deviation 1.07907 .94733 .96240 .93606 .98235 .95583 .72182 .78906 .88774 .91608 .89451 .93276 1.11633 1.10987 .97037 .88318 1.02045 1.02133 .97605 q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 * q21b q21b q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 1.00 Mean 3.0000 3.0000 3.5000 4.5000 4.5000 4.5000 4.0000 4.0000 4.5000 4.0000 3.5000 3.5000 4.0000 4.5000 4.0000 3.5000 3.5000 3.5000 3.5000 Std. Deviation .00000 .00000 .70711 .70711 .70711 .70711 .00000 .00000 .70711 .00000 .70711 .70711 1.41421 .70711 .00000 .70711 2.12132 .70711 .70711 2.00 Mean 2.9500 3.4000 3.2000 4.1000 4.0500 4.0500 4.5500 4.2500 4.7500 4.4500 3.7500 3.7000 3.0500 3.0000 3.5500 3.3500 3.5500 3.3000 3.6000 Std. Deviation 1.23438 .99472 1.00525 1.11921 1.23438 1.23438 .51042 .91047 .71635 .60481 .91047 .92338 1.19097 1.21395 .88704 .74516 1.23438 1.26074 1.04630 3.00 Mean 3.3793 3.5517 3.5862 4.3276 4.3621 4.3621 4.4655 4.2759 4.3793 4.0862 3.5862 3.4655 3.3276 3.3793 3.4483 3.2759 3.6034 3.3793 3.4655 Std. Deviation 1.15208 1.07886 1.02657 .57393 .85221 .85221 .65469 .72046 .83409 .88426 .93723 1.02966 1.17560 1.16721 1.11091 .96959 1.04192 1.08946 1.15797 4.00 Mean 3.3171 3.4634 3.5366 4.0244 4.2195 4.4634 4.2439 4.0732 4.1707 3.9024 3.5854 3.6585 3.0976 3.2683 3.4878 3.4634 3.4878 3.6098 3.6829 Std. Deviation .96018 .83957 .89715 .98711 .90863 .74490 .76748 .75466 .97217 .96966 .89375 .91131 1.09098 1.02529 .92526 .86884 .95189 .91864 .81973 5.00 Mean 3.7895 3.8947 3.7895 3.4737 3.9474 3.9474 4.1579 3.8947 4.1579 3.8421 4.0000 3.9474 3.5789 3.5789 3.7895 3.4211 3.4737 3.8947 3.5789 Std. Deviation .85498 .65784 .85498 1.26352 1.22355 1.26814 .95819 .93659 .95819 1.11869 .74536 .62126 .83771 .96124 .71328 .83771 .84119 .65784 .60698 Total Mean 3.3500 3.5429 3.5429 4.0929 4.2214 4.2929 3.3643 3.1571 3.3429 3.0500 3.6643 3.6214 3.2643 3.3357 3.5286 3.3643 3.5429 3.5071 3.5643 Std. Deviation 1.07907 .94733 .96240 .93606 .98235 .95583 .72182 .78906 .88774 .91608 .89451 .93276 1.11633 1.10987 .97037 .88318 1.02045 1.02133 .97605 q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 * q21c q21c q21_1.1 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_3.1 q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_3.5 q21_3.6 q21_4.1 q21_4.2 q21_4.3 q21_4.4 q21_4.5 q21_4.6 q21_4.7 1.00 Mean 3.6667 3.6667 3.6667 3.6667 4.0000 4.3333 3.0000 3.3333 3.3333 2.6667 3.3333 4.0000 4.3333 4.3333 4.3333 4.3333 4.6667 4.3333 4.3333 Std. Deviation 1.15470 1.15470 1.15470 1.15470 .00000 .57735 1.73205 2.08167 2.08167 1.52753 .57735 1.00000 .57735 .57735 .57735 1.15470 .57735 .57735 .57735 2.00 Mean 3.4000 3.6727 3.6364 3.9636 4.2364 4.2909 4.3636 4.0727 4.3455 4.0364 3.6545 3.6545 3.2545 3.4000 3.6000 3.3273 3.4727 3.3636 3.5636 Std. Deviation .95452 .74671 .86845 .98062 .85988 .83161 .58890 .83565 .84367 .81567 .77503 .82143 1.18974 1.13203 .85201 .74671 .97856 .86845 .89781 3.00 Mean 3.5000 3.6000 3.5667 4.3333 4.2667 4.3000 4.4333 4.3000 4.5667 4.3000 3.8667 3.6667 3.4333 3.4000 3.5667 3.4000 3.6333 3.8000 3.5667 Std. Deviation 1.07479 .93218 1.00630 .47946 1.04826 1.05536 .72793 .65126 .56832 .87691 .89955 .88409 1.00630 1.06997 1.04000 .81368 .99943 .99655 .97143 4.00 Mean 3.1875 3.3750 3.4375 4.2292 4.3125 4.4167 4.3750 4.2500 4.2500 4.0417 3.5625 3.5417 3.1042 3.1458 3.3542 3.3125 3.5208 3.4792 3.5625 Std. Deviation 1.17882 1.08422 .98729 .88100 .92613 .84635 .73296 .63581 1.00000 .96664 1.00861 1.09074 1.11545 1.11068 1.08156 1.03464 1.11068 1.14835 1.04995 5.00 Mean 3.2500 3.2500 3.2500 2.7500 2.7500 2.7500 4.7500 3.7500 4.5000 3.5000 3.7500 3.5000 3.2500 3.5000 3.7500 3.5000 3.2500 3.0000 3.0000 Std. Deviation 1.70783 1.70783 1.70783 2.06155 2.06155 2.06155 .50000 1.25831 .57735 .57735 1.25831 1.00000 .95743 1.29099 .50000 1.00000 .50000 1.41421 1.41421 Total Mean 3.3500 3.5429 3.5429 4.0929 4.2214 4.2929 3.3643 3.1571 3.3429 3.0500 3.6643 3.6214 3.2643 3.3357 3.5286 3.3643 3.5429 3.5071 3.5643 Std. Deviation 1.07907 .94733 .96240 .93606 .98235 .95583 .72182 .78906 .88774 .91608 .89451 .93276 1.11633 1.10987 .97037 .88318 1.02045 1.02133 .97605 Ph ụ lục số 29 Estimates (Group number 1 - Default model) Scalar Estimates (Group number 1 - Default model) Maximum Likelihood Estimates Regression Weights: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label F1 <--- 1 -.023 .070 -.332 .740 F1 <--- 3 .001 .059 .009 .993 F1 <--- 4 -.174 .102 -1.698 .089 F1 <--- 2 .087 .063 1.382 .167 q21_4.2 <--- 1 1.000 q21_4.5 <--- 1 .957 .112 8.569 *** q21_4.1 <--- 1 .991 .085 11.683 *** q21_4.3 <--- 1 .961 .107 8.998 *** q21_4.4 <--- 1 .762 .097 7.853 *** q21_4.7 <--- 1 .708 .107 6.639 *** q21_1.1 <--- 2 1.000 q21_1.3 <--- 2 .793 .053 14.956 *** q21_1.2 <--- 2 .754 .054 13.967 *** q21_2.3 <--- 3 1.000 q21_2.2 <--- 3 .972 .075 12.943 *** q21_2.1 <--- 3 .685 .077 8.875 *** q21_3.4 <--- 4 1.000 q21_3.3 <--- 4 .794 .119 6.671 *** q21_3.2 <--- 4 .686 .104 6.573 *** q21a <--- F1 1.000 q21b <--- F1 1.585 .546 2.901 .004 q21c <--- F1 .053 .117 .456 .649 Standardized Regression Weights: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate F1 <--- 1 -.030 F1 <--- 3 .001 F1 <--- 4 -.208 F1 <--- 2 .140 q21_4.2 <--- 1 .740 q21_4.5 <--- 1 .770 q21_4.1 <--- 1 .734 q21_4.3 <--- 1 .814 q21_4.4 <--- 1 .709 q21_4.7 <--- 1 .596 q21_1.1 <--- 2 .964 q21_1.3 <--- 2 .857 q21_1.2 <--- 2 .828 q21_2.3 <--- 3 .943 Estimate q21_2.2 <--- 3 .891 q21_2.1 <--- 3 .660 q21_3.4 <--- 4 .838 q21_3.3 <--- 4 .687 q21_3.2 <--- 4 .668 q21a <--- F1 .691 q21b <--- F1 1.081 q21c <--- F1 .035 Covariances: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label 1 2 .308 .087 3.546 *** 1 3 -.094 .070 -1.345 .179 1 4 -.009 .063 -.135 .893 2 3 .010 .084 .118 .906 2 4 -.076 .078 -.977 .329 3 4 .184 .070 2.614 .009 e1 e3 .281 .072 3.900 *** e3 e5 -.110 .040 -2.759 .006 Correlations: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate 1 2 .363 1 3 -.128 1 4 -.014 2 3 .011 2 4 -.096 3 4 .267 e1 e3 .505 e3 e5 -.237 Variances: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label 1 .670 .140 4.794 *** 2 1.074 .144 7.437 *** 3 .807 .118 6.834 *** 4 .586 .118 4.950 *** e19 .383 .142 2.703 .007 e1 .553 .083 6.696 *** e2 .420 .064 6.570 *** Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label e3 .563 .088 6.411 *** e4 .316 .053 5.925 *** e5 .386 .055 6.979 *** e6 .610 .079 7.689 *** e7 .082 .043 1.923 .055 e8 .245 .039 6.204 *** e9 .281 .041 6.789 *** e10 .100 .049 2.054 .040 e11 .197 .051 3.888 *** e12 .491 .063 7.762 *** e13 .248 .076 3.261 .001 e14 .413 .067 6.149 *** e15 .342 .053 6.414 *** e16 .450 .147 3.066 .002 e17 -.149 .343 -.433 .665 e18 .933 .112 8.338 *** Squared Multiple Correlations: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate F1 .066 q21c .001 q21b 1.169 q21a .477 q21_3.2 .446 q21_3.3 .472 q21_3.4 .703 q21_2.1 .435 q21_2.2 .795 q21_2.3 .889 q21_1.2 .685 q21_1.3 .734 q21_1.1 .929 q21_4.7 .355 q21_4.4 .502 q21_4.3 .662 q21_4.1 .539 q21_4.5 .593 q21_4.2 .548 Matrices (Group number 1 - Default model) Residual Covariances (Group number 1 - Default model) q21c q21b q21a q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_1.1 q21_4.7 q21_4.4 q21_4.3 q21_4.1 q21_4.5 q21_4.2 q21c .000 q21b .001 .000 q21a .021 .000 .000 q21_3.2 .081 .013 .036 .000 q21_3.3 .024 -.027 -.061 -.002 .000 q21_3.4 .036 .016 .055 -.003 .003 .000 q21_2.1 .040 -.170 -.078 .171 .104 .170 .000 q21_2.2 -.048 -.015 -.038 -.007 -.032 -.047 -.007 .000 q21_2.3 -.045 .030 .027 .049 -.046 -.013 -.001 .001 .000 q21_1.2 -.135 -.010 .060 -.032 .024 -.013 -.141 -.077 -.116 .000 q21_1.3 -.099 -.009 .091 -.016 -.024 -.010 -.006 .122 .097 -.008 .000 q21_1.1 -.100 .020 .038 -.003 .040 -.006 -.082 .027 -.005 .000 .002 .000 q21_4.7 -.066 .021 .100 -.106 -.032 -.086 .065 -.017 -.013 .179 .078 .106 .000 q21_4.4 -.038 .027 .075 .012 .073 .067 .037 -.039 -.013 .018 .009 -.055 .040 .000 q21_4.3 -.110 .023 .011 -.006 .075 .075 .042 -.036 .022 .076 -.014 .026 .017 .010 .000 q21_4.1 -.098 .026 .042 -.100 -.155 -.040 -.025 -.053 -.020 .120 -.064 -.019 -.048 -.028 -.014 .016 q21_4.5 -.046 -.054 .072 -.023 -.080 .052 .033 -.018 .046 .019 .001 -.099 -.025 .014 -.032 .057 .000 q21_4.2 -.124 .041 .056 -.118 -.101 -.037 .041 .010 .046 .107 .003 .018 -.071 -.054 .043 .016 .027 .000 Standardized Residual Covariances (Group number 1 - Default model) q21c q21b q21a q21_3.2 q21_3.3 q21_3.4 q21_2.1 q21_2.2 q21_2.3 q21_1.2 q21_1.3 q21_1.1 q21_4.7 q21_4.4 q21_4.3 q21_4.1 q21_4.5 q21_4.2 q21c .000 q21b .011 .000 q21a .276 .001 .000 q21_3.2 1.256 .206 .573 .000 q21_3.3 .330 -.380 -.875 -.025 .000 q21_3.4 .483 .217 .764 -.036 .044 .000 q21_2.1 .524 -2.286 -1.058 2.723 1.475 2.323 .000 q21_2.2 -.595 -.187 -.494 -.109 -.429 -.603 -.082 .000 q21_2.3 -.578 .396 .361 .767 -.638 -.167 -.014 .013 .000 q21_1.2 -1.739 -.136 .799 -.505 .332 -.176 -1.891 -.988 -1.527 .000 q21_1.3 -1.260 -.120 1.207 -.242 -.335 -.134 -.076 1.534 1.258 -.084 .000 q21_1.1 -1.133 .226 .447 -.042 .497 -.072 -.966 .304 -.061 .003 .013 .000 q21_4.7 -.828 .275 1.303 -1.634 -.432 -1.148 .841 -.213 -.162 2.269 .972 1.172 .000 q21_4.4 -.520 .391 1.079 .196 1.108 .981 .528 -.538 -.188 .256 .128 -.661 .510 .000 q21_4.3 -1.392 .301 .141 -.093 1.038 .997 .542 -.448 .275 .952 -.175 .289 .192 .115 .000 q21_4.1 -1.086 .300 .481 -1.357 -1.873 -.473 -.283 -.580 -.219 1.319 -.691 -.181 -.482 -.310 -.132 .108 q21_4.5 -.546 -.664 .903 -.333 -1.044 .666 .407 -.216 .552 .230 .007 -1.026 -.266 .161 -.324 .519 .000 q21_4.2 -1.372 .466 .643 -1.604 -1.219 -.430 .463 .110 .513 1.183 .027 .170 -.713 -.582 .402 .118 .242 .000