Luận án Nghiên cứu thương hiệu tổ chức và thương hiệu cá nhân trong lĩnh vực báo chí tại Việt Nam

Từ quá trình NC, kết hợp với kinh nghiệm thực tiễn, xin khuyến nghị một số giải pháp nhằm phát triển THBC tại Việt Nam: Một là, các cơ quan BC cần có chiến lược/kế hoạch phát triển song song THTC và THCN. Trong một cơ quan BC có nhiều cá nhân nhà báo có TH sẽ góp phần làm cho giá trị TH của cơ quan BC đó tăng lên. Ngược lại, nếu làm việc trong các cơ quan BC có TH, cá nhân các nhà báo thường có TH hơn những nhà báo làm việc trong các cơ quan BC không có TH. Hai là, các cơ quan BC nên đẩy mạnh đào tạo chuyên ngành BC cho đội ngũ nhà báo. Các kiến thức chuyên ngành giúp cho nhà báo am hiểu hơn về BC, có tính khoa học, hệ thống về lý luận BC. Ba là, mỗi cơ quan BC, cá nhân các nhà báo cần có sự hiểu biết về THBC. Từ đó, cùng với việc tổ chức khảo sát, NC một cách khoa học sẽ có sự nỗ lực phát triển TH. Bốn là, Chính phủ sớm hoàn tất Đề án Quy hoạch BC. Sau khi xác định rõ mô hình hoạt động, CQBC nào tồn tại, cơ quan nào sáp nhập hay giải thể, Chính phủ cần có chiếnlược phát triển BC, trong đó chú trọng đến vấn đề nghiên cứu và phát triển TH trong lĩnh vực BC. Năm là, cần thành lập các trung tâm NC, hỗ trợ phát triển THBC. Trong đó, cần có sự tham gia của các trường đại học, viện, trung tâm NC, các CQBC để hỗ trợ cho các tổ chức, cá nhân có nhu cầu phát triển THBC. Sáu là, TPHCM cần chủ động hơn trong NC, phát triển một số mô hình THBC trong lĩnh vực BC. TPHCM là địa phương đang trực tiếp quản lý 38 cơ quan BC- nhiều nhất và có quy mô lớn nhất trong cả nước, trong đó có nhiều cơ quan BC có TH.Tại TPHCM hiện nay có khoảng 9.000 nhà báo được cấp thẻ nhà báo, trong đó có nhiều nhà báo có TH và hàng chục ngàn sinh viên, cộng tác viên BC. Bên cạnh đó, tại TPHCM còn có nhiều trường đại học lớn với lực lượng chuyên gia, nhà nghiên cứu về lĩnh vực BC có uy tín. Trong thời gian tới, TPHCM cần tổ chức các cuộc hội thảo về THTC và THCN trong lĩnh vực BC. Qua đó sẽ đúc kết các lý luận và thực tiễn về TH trong lĩnh vực BC; làm nền tảng để NC và phát triển THBC trong tương lai. Bảy là, mỗi nhà báo cần chủ động, tích cực trong việc tìm hiểu, học tập, NC về THBC nói chung, THCN nói riêng. Trong đó, cần tích cực tham gia các hội thảo, tọa đàm, trao đổi kinh nghiệm về THBC để có nhận thức đúng và đầy đủ hơn về THCN, các YTTĐ đến THCN, MQH giữa THTC và THCN. Mỗi nhà báo cũng cần có ý thức hơn về giá trị TH cơ quan BC mà mình đang làm việc và THCN của chính mình. Đồng thời phải luôn suy nghĩ, trăn trở về sự phát triển của THBC, trong đó có THCN của chính mình và các đồng nghiệp. Mỗi nhà báo phải tự xây dựng một kế hoạch, lộ trình phát triển THCN. Điều quan trọng là kế hoạch, lộ trình của cá nhân mỗi nhà báo phải phù hợp với kế hoạch phát triển TH của CQBC nơi mình công tác.Tám là, các CQBC nên đầu tư NC, hoặc phối hợp với các trường đại học, các viện NC nhằm NC bài bản, khoa học về THBC nói chung, THCN nói riêng. Trong quá trình NC, cần chú trọng NC về MQH giữa THTC và THCN; các YTTĐ đến THCN trong lĩnh vực. Từ sự NC, hiểu biết sâu sắc và có cơ sở khoa học đó, mỗi cơ quan BC cần xây dựng một kế hoạch tổng thể về TH trong tương lai. Với các giải pháp nêu trên, nếu triển khai đồng bộ, quyết liệt sẽ nâng cao THBC, góp phần quan trọng vào quá trình phát triển của hệ thống BC của Việt Nam. 5.3. HẠN CHẾ VÀ CÁC NC TIẾP THEO 5.3.1. Hạn chế của NC Bên cạnh những đóng góp, đề tài cũng còn hạn chế như: Mặc dù đã có sự kết nối với các CQBC, cá nhân các nhà báo ở khắp các vùng miền của đất nước, nhưng kết quả khảo sát phần lớn tập trung vào đối tượng nhà báo đang sống, làm việc tại TPHCM. TPHCM là trung tâm BC lớn nhất cả nước, là nơi tập trung lực lượng nhà báo đông đảo nhất nước với hơn 9.000 nhà báo được cấp thẻ, là nơi tập trung các nhà báo có quê quán ở cả ba miền Nam, Trung, Bắc, là nơi có nhiều nhà báo kinh nghiệm, tên tuổi.Tuy nhiên, vì đề tài xác định phạm vi ”lĩnh vực BC tại Việt Nam” nên kết quả khảo sát chưa đạt được tính đại diện toàn diện như mong muốn. Một số biến quan sát trong thang đo THCN không nên để nhà báo tự đánh giá về mình vì có thể không đảm bảo tính khách quan. 5.3.2. Các NC tiếp theo Các NC sau có thể tiếp tục NC về các yếu tố bên trong như sự lôi cuốn, sự thu hút, sự tin cậy, tin tưởng. Các NC tiếp theo có thể NC về THCN trong các lĩnh vực khác như: giáo dục, y tế, kinh doanh... Các NC tiếp theo có thể NC về mối quan hệ hai chiều giữa các thành phần của THTC với nhau và sự tác động của THCN đối với THTC; sự tác động của THCN đối với từng thành phần của THTC.

pdf322 trang | Chia sẻ: yenxoi77 | Lượt xem: 617 | Lượt tải: 0download
Bạn đang xem trước 20 trang tài liệu Luận án Nghiên cứu thương hiệu tổ chức và thương hiệu cá nhân trong lĩnh vực báo chí tại Việt Nam, để xem tài liệu hoàn chỉnh bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
.937 4.451 7 1.375 2.749 56.074 .942 1.885 49.822 5.096 8 1.237 2.474 58.548 .722 1.444 51.266 2.470 9 1.166 2.333 60.881 .666 1.333 52.599 5.561 10 1.063 2.126 63.007 .605 1.210 53.809 4.838 11 .988 1.976 64.983 12 .949 1.899 66.882 13 .905 1.811 68.693 14 .823 1.645 70.338 15 .794 1.588 71.926 16 .771 1.542 73.468 17 .729 1.458 74.926 18 .705 1.410 76.336 19 .658 1.316 77.652 20 .640 1.280 78.932 21 .627 1.255 80.186 22 .590 1.180 81.367 23 .557 1.114 82.480 24 .532 1.064 83.544 25 .516 1.032 84.576 26 .494 .989 85.565 27 .484 .968 86.533 28 .460 .919 87.452 xxxix 29 .431 .861 88.314 30 .427 .855 89.168 31 .415 .831 89.999 32 .386 .771 90.770 33 .380 .759 91.530 34 .355 .711 92.240 35 .346 .692 92.932 36 .335 .669 93.601 37 .319 .638 94.239 38 .299 .597 94.836 39 .292 .584 95.420 40 .278 .556 95.976 41 .251 .502 96.478 42 .240 .479 96.958 43 .234 .468 97.426 44 .232 .464 97.890 45 .203 .406 98.296 46 .201 .402 98.698 47 .193 .386 99.084 48 .187 .374 99.458 49 .142 .285 99.743 50 .129 .257 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN10 .921 KN9 .881 KN11 .857 KN7 .774 KN8 .696 KN6 .537 .431 KNHT5 .511 .357 GT1 .423 THCN5 .338 -.211 KN1 .314 .202 .254 .212 TĐ4 .845 TĐ5 .788 TĐ6 .751 TĐ3 .720 TĐ2 .614 xl TĐ1 .601 .210 KT2 .847 .204 KT4 .820 KT3 .813 KT1 .706 .207 KT5 .651 -.211 KT6 .532 .334 THCN4 .258 .285 .236 THCN7 -.217 .951 THCN2 .806 -.210 THCN1 .790 -.523 THCN3 .583 THCN8 .472 NL2 .428 .231 NL3 .204 .370 .296 PTHT1 .670 -.212 PTHT2 .525 .274 NL1 .433 PTHT5 .251 .374 .296 -.221 PTHT3 -.203 .638 PTHT4 -.210 .621 PTHT6 .211 .423 GT2 .284 .257 .286 GT4 .807 GT5 .739 GT3 .218 .512 KN3 .769 KN2 .256 .575 KNHT2 .273 .529 KNHT1 .271 .476 KNHT4 .266 .397 NL4 .336 .363 .205 KNHT3 .295 KN5 .375 .564 KN4 .314 .319 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 10 iterations. xli 6.4.Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 4: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .919 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 13681.438 df 1176 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 14.317 29.219 29.219 13.889 28.346 28.346 10.648 2 3.861 7.879 37.099 3.456 7.052 35.398 8.450 3 2.555 5.214 42.312 2.079 4.244 39.642 7.970 4 2.328 4.751 47.063 1.868 3.812 43.454 8.590 5 1.725 3.521 50.584 1.257 2.566 46.020 3.739 6 1.398 2.853 53.437 .969 1.977 47.996 5.416 7 1.367 2.790 56.227 .908 1.853 49.850 5.382 8 1.237 2.524 58.751 .724 1.478 51.328 6.711 9 1.154 2.356 61.107 .659 1.344 52.672 2.460 10 1.062 2.167 63.274 .600 1.224 53.896 4.709 11 .988 2.016 65.289 12 .949 1.937 67.226 13 .878 1.792 69.019 14 .822 1.677 70.696 15 .790 1.611 72.308 16 .771 1.573 73.880 17 .727 1.484 75.364 18 .683 1.393 76.757 19 .648 1.323 78.080 20 .633 1.292 79.373 21 .597 1.218 80.590 22 .575 1.173 81.763 23 .548 1.119 82.882 24 .532 1.085 83.967 25 .503 1.026 84.994 26 .487 .993 85.987 27 .482 .984 86.971 xlii 28 .457 .934 87.905 29 .427 .872 88.777 30 .415 .848 89.625 31 .389 .794 90.419 32 .380 .775 91.194 33 .366 .747 91.941 34 .352 .718 92.658 35 .345 .704 93.362 36 .324 .661 94.023 37 .303 .619 94.642 38 .296 .604 95.246 39 .280 .572 95.817 40 .256 .522 96.339 41 .243 .496 96.835 42 .239 .487 97.322 43 .234 .478 97.800 44 .221 .451 98.250 45 .202 .413 98.663 46 .195 .398 99.060 47 .187 .382 99.442 48 .144 .295 99.737 49 .129 .263 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN10 .903 KN9 .862 KN11 .841 KN7 .762 KN8 .687 KN6 .521 .439 KNHT5 .492 .384 GT1 .417 THCN5 .353 -.216 KN1 .313 .253 -.202 .221 TĐ4 .826 TĐ5 .784 TĐ6 .735 TĐ3 .707 TĐ2 .596 xliii TĐ1 .579 .212 KT2 .826 .204 KT4 .800 KT3 .792 KT1 .689 .206 KT5 .653 -.242 KT6 .524 .340 THCN7 -.205 .913 THCN2 .799 -.201 THCN1 .789 -.500 THCN3 .208 .576 THCN8 .479 NL2 .408 .237 NL3 .203 .366 .292 PTHT1 .676 -.215 PTHT2 .532 .269 NL1 .430 PTHT5 .251 .369 .268 -.230 PTHT4 -.215 .682 PTHT3 -.205 .636 PTHT6 .206 .433 GT2 .276 .239 .291 GT4 .819 GT5 .751 GT3 .523 KNHT2 .255 .543 KNHT1 .230 .513 KNHT4 .225 .427 NL4 .319 .368 .202 KNHT3 .323 KN3 .757 KN2 .237 .583 KN5 .366 .568 KN4 .299 .319 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 10 iterations. xliv 6.5. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 5: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .917 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 13240.759 df 1128 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 13.903 28.965 28.965 13.476 28.074 28.074 10.019 2 3.828 7.975 36.939 3.422 7.130 35.204 8.296 3 2.532 5.275 42.214 2.065 4.302 39.506 8.180 4 2.301 4.794 47.009 1.828 3.809 43.315 7.914 5 1.708 3.558 50.567 1.242 2.587 45.902 3.589 6 1.392 2.900 53.467 .966 2.013 47.915 5.000 7 1.350 2.813 56.280 .892 1.858 49.773 4.514 8 1.236 2.575 58.855 .725 1.511 51.284 6.893 9 1.154 2.403 61.258 .657 1.370 52.653 3.005 10 1.053 2.194 63.452 .597 1.244 53.897 4.531 11 .975 2.032 65.484 12 .948 1.976 67.459 13 .853 1.776 69.236 14 .816 1.700 70.935 15 .789 1.645 72.580 16 .765 1.593 74.173 17 .712 1.483 75.656 18 .683 1.422 77.078 19 .634 1.320 78.398 20 .618 1.288 79.686 21 .592 1.233 80.919 22 .572 1.191 82.109 23 .540 1.125 83.234 24 .531 1.106 84.341 25 .495 1.032 85.373 26 .485 1.010 86.383 27 .482 1.004 87.387 28 .454 .946 88.333 xlv 29 .423 .880 89.213 30 .392 .816 90.030 31 .389 .811 90.841 32 .368 .766 91.606 33 .355 .739 92.346 34 .345 .719 93.065 35 .339 .707 93.772 36 .319 .665 94.437 37 .299 .623 95.060 38 .292 .608 95.668 39 .266 .555 96.223 40 .251 .523 96.745 41 .241 .503 97.248 42 .234 .488 97.736 43 .221 .460 98.197 44 .203 .423 98.619 45 .199 .415 99.034 46 .187 .390 99.424 47 .147 .306 99.730 48 .130 .270 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN10 .883 KN9 .840 KN11 .819 KN7 .725 .204 KN8 .665 KN6 .504 .485 KNHT5 .470 .398 GT1 .388 THCN5 .336 KN1 .303 .245 -.209 .226 TĐ4 .829 TĐ5 .789 TĐ6 .735 TĐ3 .710 TĐ2 .598 TĐ1 .578 .216 KT2 .847 .209 xlvi KT4 .807 KT3 .806 KT1 .709 KT5 .673 -.233 KT6 .532 .336 THCN7 -.200 .863 THCN2 .763 THCN1 .217 .762 -.440 THCN3 .212 .552 THCN8 .454 NL2 .397 .258 NL3 .350 .297 PTHT1 .681 -.223 PTHT2 .545 .227 NL1 .422 PTHT5 .255 .373 -.217 .258 GT4 .814 GT5 .751 GT3 .513 PTHT4 -.205 .689 PTHT3 .661 PTHT6 .212 .421 KNHT2 .243 .557 KNHT1 .224 .495 KNHT4 .228 .440 NL4 .308 .397 KNHT3 .329 KN3 .753 KN2 .226 .614 KN5 .338 .580 KN4 .289 .349 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 10 iterations. 6.6. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 6: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .916 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 12844.801 df 1081 Sig. 0.000 xlvii Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 13.510 28.744 28.744 13.088 27.846 27.846 9.782 2 3.822 8.131 36.875 3.417 7.270 35.117 8.199 3 2.522 5.365 42.240 2.053 4.367 39.484 7.783 4 2.301 4.895 47.135 1.825 3.884 43.368 7.771 5 1.701 3.620 50.756 1.230 2.616 45.984 4.193 6 1.382 2.940 53.696 .968 2.060 48.044 5.333 7 1.347 2.867 56.563 .872 1.856 49.900 6.991 8 1.198 2.550 59.113 .696 1.480 51.380 3.055 9 1.141 2.428 61.540 .658 1.401 52.781 1.950 10 1.050 2.235 63.775 .565 1.202 53.983 3.709 11 .949 2.020 65.795 12 .942 2.005 67.800 13 .848 1.805 69.606 14 .812 1.728 71.334 15 .789 1.679 73.013 16 .753 1.601 74.614 17 .712 1.514 76.128 18 .653 1.389 77.517 19 .630 1.341 78.858 20 .598 1.273 80.131 21 .583 1.240 81.370 22 .569 1.211 82.581 23 .532 1.132 83.713 24 .513 1.092 84.805 25 .489 1.040 85.845 26 .483 1.027 86.872 27 .458 .975 87.847 28 .425 .904 88.751 29 .396 .843 89.594 30 .392 .833 90.428 31 .369 .786 91.214 32 .366 .779 91.993 33 .352 .748 92.741 34 .340 .724 93.466 35 .327 .697 94.162 36 .310 .659 94.821 37 .293 .624 95.445 xlviii 38 .290 .617 96.062 39 .266 .567 96.629 40 .242 .515 97.144 41 .238 .507 97.652 42 .224 .476 98.127 43 .209 .445 98.572 44 .201 .428 99.000 45 .190 .404 99.404 46 .147 .313 99.717 47 .133 .283 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN10 .891 KN9 .845 KN11 .826 KN7 .737 KN8 .668 KN6 .533 .417 KNHT5 .472 .402 GT1 .386 THCN5 .335 -.251 TĐ4 .835 TĐ5 .787 TĐ6 .738 TĐ3 .693 TĐ2 .572 TĐ1 .565 .216 KT2 .823 .202 KT3 .792 KT4 .774 KT1 .699 .219 KT5 .693 -.254 KT6 .528 .323 THCN7 .942 THCN2 .727 -.213 THCN1 .209 .670 -.507 THCN3 .219 .508 THCN8 .486 NL2 .475 .205 xlix NL3 .356 .308 PTHT1 .615 PTHT2 .570 .208 PTHT5 .252 .512 -.208 NL1 .402 PTHT6 .381 .339 GT4 .810 GT5 .761 GT3 .511 KNHT1 .227 .590 KNHT2 .258 .525 KNHT4 .225 .435 NL4 .334 .373 KNHT3 .301 .228 PTHT4 .628 PTHT3 -.219 .388 .619 KN3 -.240 .717 KN2 .275 .566 KN5 .374 .533 KN4 .320 .325 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a 6.7. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 7: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .914 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 12495.048 df 1035 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 13.128 28.540 28.540 12.711 27.632 27.632 9.732 2 3.799 8.259 36.798 3.396 7.383 35.015 8.041 3 2.515 5.468 42.267 2.046 4.449 39.463 7.665 4 2.299 4.998 47.265 1.828 3.974 43.438 7.294 5 1.700 3.695 50.960 1.227 2.667 46.104 4.794 6 1.372 2.983 53.943 .971 2.110 48.215 5.739 l 7 1.330 2.892 56.835 .842 1.830 50.045 7.030 8 1.198 2.603 59.439 .693 1.506 51.551 1.693 9 1.140 2.478 61.917 .651 1.416 52.966 .972 10 1.018 2.213 64.130 .543 1.180 54.146 1.614 11 .946 2.058 66.187 12 .937 2.037 68.225 13 .833 1.811 70.036 14 .810 1.760 71.796 15 .786 1.709 73.505 16 .713 1.551 75.056 17 .705 1.532 76.588 18 .652 1.417 78.005 19 .630 1.370 79.375 20 .584 1.269 80.644 21 .569 1.237 81.881 22 .540 1.174 83.055 23 .527 1.145 84.200 24 .507 1.103 85.303 25 .483 1.050 86.353 26 .462 1.004 87.357 27 .444 .966 88.323 28 .411 .894 89.217 29 .393 .854 90.071 30 .386 .838 90.909 31 .367 .797 91.707 32 .357 .775 92.482 33 .341 .740 93.222 34 .340 .738 93.961 35 .312 .678 94.639 36 .307 .667 95.306 37 .292 .634 95.940 38 .266 .579 96.519 39 .242 .527 97.046 40 .239 .519 97.565 41 .228 .496 98.061 42 .217 .472 98.533 43 .201 .438 98.971 44 .193 .420 99.390 45 .147 .320 99.710 46 .133 .290 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. li Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN11 .869 KN10 .868 KN9 .804 .214 KN7 .783 KN8 .706 KN6 .623 KNHT5 .491 .398 KN5 .475 -.267 GT1 .377 .202 THCN5 .370 -.327 TĐ4 .860 TĐ5 .810 TĐ6 .749 TĐ3 .708 TĐ2 .568 TĐ1 .554 .226 KT2 .835 .230 KT3 .788 KT4 .762 KT1 .733 .273 KT5 .723 -.261 KT6 .271 .557 -.204 THCN7 .933 NL2 .613 THCN2 .549 .400 THCN8 .522 NL4 .459 .316 NL3 .246 .402 .228 THCN3 .225 .394 .277 PTHT3 -.232 .663 -.209 .278 PTHT5 .243 .586 -.206 PTHT2 .564 .215 PTHT6 .500 PTHT1 .499 .229 NL1 .259 -.254 GT4 .804 GT5 .758 GT3 .516 KNHT1 .208 -.235 .649 lii 6.8. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 8: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .916 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 12145.259 df 990 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 12.961 28.803 28.803 12.548 27.885 27.885 9.183 2 3.711 8.247 37.050 3.312 7.360 35.245 7.860 3 2.483 5.517 42.567 2.028 4.506 39.751 7.711 4 2.224 4.943 47.509 1.735 3.856 43.607 7.184 5 1.691 3.757 51.267 1.245 2.767 46.375 4.674 6 1.372 3.049 54.316 .982 2.182 48.556 5.216 7 1.295 2.877 57.193 .829 1.843 50.399 6.594 8 1.150 2.556 59.749 .668 1.485 51.884 1.620 9 1.131 2.513 62.262 .629 1.397 53.281 .922 10 1.013 2.251 64.512 .537 1.194 54.476 1.508 11 .942 2.093 66.605 12 .868 1.928 68.533 13 .825 1.834 70.367 14 .807 1.793 72.160 15 .776 1.724 73.884 16 .713 1.586 75.470 17 .688 1.529 76.998 KNHT2 .300 .238 .499 KNHT4 .232 .444 KNHT3 .317 .235 KN3 .658 -.219 KN2 .297 .575 THCN1 .376 .672 PTHT4 .280 .506 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 12 iterations. liii 18 .637 1.415 78.413 19 .630 1.400 79.813 20 .571 1.268 81.081 21 .564 1.254 82.335 22 .534 1.186 83.521 23 .527 1.171 84.691 24 .495 1.101 85.792 25 .463 1.028 86.821 26 .454 1.009 87.829 27 .421 .936 88.765 28 .400 .888 89.653 29 .393 .873 90.526 30 .379 .842 91.368 31 .359 .797 92.165 32 .342 .760 92.925 33 .341 .757 93.681 34 .314 .699 94.380 35 .307 .683 95.063 36 .304 .676 95.739 37 .282 .626 96.364 38 .266 .592 96.957 39 .239 .531 97.487 40 .229 .508 97.996 41 .218 .486 98.481 42 .202 .449 98.930 43 .193 .429 99.360 44 .155 .344 99.703 45 .133 .297 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN11 .907 KN10 .797 .390 KN7 .765 .202 KN8 .744 KN9 .707 .550 KN6 .661 KN5 .523 -.276 THCN5 .487 KNHT5 .476 .382 liv TĐ4 .882 TĐ5 .826 TĐ6 .743 TĐ3 .716 TĐ2 .570 TĐ1 .541 .229 KT2 .907 KT1 .801 KT4 .754 KT3 .748 KT5 .716 -.258 KT6 .316 .539 -.204 THCN7 .914 NL2 .599 .211 THCN2 .580 .396 THCN8 .221 .520 NL4 .425 .292 THCN3 .250 .415 .281 NL3 .298 .390 .238 PTHT2 .606 PTHT5 .248 .589 PTHT1 .572 PTHT3 .203 -.213 .563 PTHT6 .498 NL1 .277 GT4 .809 GT5 .768 GT3 .498 KNHT1 -.235 .683 KNHT2 .323 .227 .487 KNHT4 .250 .430 KNHT3 .304 KN3 .765 KN2 .280 .539 THCN1 .436 .667 GT1 .301 .378 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 13 iterations. lv 6.9. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 9: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .915 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 11692.632 df 946 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 12.516 28.446 28.446 12.102 27.505 27.505 9.125 2 3.698 8.405 36.851 3.296 7.492 34.997 7.535 3 2.460 5.591 42.442 2.007 4.560 39.558 7.669 4 2.224 5.055 47.497 1.732 3.937 43.495 6.800 5 1.688 3.837 51.334 1.242 2.822 46.317 3.430 6 1.359 3.088 54.421 .955 2.170 48.487 5.039 7 1.290 2.933 57.354 .828 1.883 50.370 6.601 8 1.144 2.601 59.955 .665 1.511 51.881 1.439 9 1.130 2.569 62.523 .612 1.392 53.273 .990 10 1.010 2.295 64.818 .498 1.133 54.405 2.624 11 .913 2.075 66.893 12 .857 1.949 68.841 13 .808 1.837 70.678 14 .791 1.798 72.476 15 .762 1.733 74.208 16 .711 1.615 75.823 17 .688 1.563 77.386 18 .636 1.445 78.831 19 .574 1.305 80.136 20 .566 1.287 81.423 21 .564 1.282 82.705 22 .532 1.210 83.915 23 .496 1.126 85.041 24 .492 1.117 86.158 25 .462 1.051 87.209 26 .450 1.022 88.231 27 .416 .945 89.176 28 .399 .908 90.083 lvi 29 .379 .861 90.945 30 .371 .844 91.789 31 .348 .792 92.580 32 .342 .776 93.357 33 .325 .738 94.095 34 .314 .714 94.809 35 .304 .692 95.501 36 .298 .678 96.179 37 .267 .606 96.784 38 .252 .572 97.356 39 .239 .543 97.899 40 .225 .512 98.411 41 .208 .472 98.883 42 .202 .459 99.342 43 .155 .353 99.695 44 .134 .305 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 KN10 .902 KN11 .844 KN9 .784 KN7 .760 KN8 .683 KN6 .595 KNHT5 .453 .397 KN5 .441 -.308 TĐ4 .887 TĐ5 .830 TĐ6 .730 TĐ3 .715 TĐ2 .575 TĐ1 .532 .216 KT2 .881 KT3 .783 .205 KT4 .774 KT1 .770 -.243 KT5 .729 -.261 KT6 .261 .545 -.225 THCN7 .976 lvii THCN2 .671 .371 NL2 .541 .243 THCN8 .534 THCN3 .204 .443 .268 NL4 .404 .321 NL3 .227 .373 .217 .216 PTHT2 .585 PTHT3 .213 .561 PTHT1 .557 PTHT5 .227 .531 -.202 .219 PTHT6 .458 GT4 .813 GT5 .754 GT3 .505 KNHT1 -.228 .637 KNHT2 .282 .228 .505 KNHT4 .252 .440 KNHT3 .316 KN3 .769 KN2 .270 .576 THCN1 .528 .664 THCN5 .341 .414 NL1 .240 .310 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 9 iterations. 6.10. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 10: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .917 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 11589.425 df 903 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 12.500 29.069 29.069 12.073 28.078 28.078 9.007 lviii 2 3.683 8.565 37.634 3.271 7.607 35.684 7.526 3 2.430 5.651 43.284 1.982 4.609 40.294 7.438 4 2.212 5.143 48.428 1.704 3.963 44.257 6.984 5 1.667 3.878 52.305 1.200 2.790 47.047 3.740 6 1.353 3.146 55.451 .939 2.185 49.232 5.108 7 1.289 2.998 58.449 .816 1.898 51.130 6.366 8 1.134 2.638 61.088 .647 1.506 52.636 1.923 9 1.046 2.432 63.520 .590 1.371 54.007 2.538 10 .930 2.162 65.682 11 .877 2.040 67.721 12 .852 1.981 69.702 13 .796 1.851 71.554 14 .769 1.789 73.342 15 .717 1.667 75.010 16 .694 1.613 76.623 17 .658 1.531 78.154 18 .595 1.385 79.538 19 .572 1.330 80.869 20 .564 1.311 82.180 21 .536 1.247 83.427 22 .496 1.154 84.581 23 .492 1.145 85.725 24 .471 1.096 86.821 25 .451 1.048 87.869 26 .429 .998 88.867 27 .400 .930 89.797 28 .381 .885 90.682 29 .372 .865 91.547 30 .349 .811 92.357 31 .342 .795 93.153 32 .325 .755 93.908 33 .322 .749 94.657 34 .309 .718 95.375 35 .299 .695 96.070 36 .267 .620 96.690 37 .254 .591 97.282 38 .239 .555 97.837 39 .225 .524 98.361 40 .210 .487 98.849 41 .203 .473 99.321 42 .156 .363 99.684 43 .136 .316 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. lix a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 KN10 .877 KN11 .865 KN9 .758 KN7 .733 KN8 .689 KN6 .566 .273 KNHT5 .438 .403 THCN5 .398 TĐ4 .882 TĐ5 .831 TĐ6 .725 TĐ3 .718 TĐ2 .570 TĐ1 .535 KT2 .885 .204 KT4 .768 KT1 .761 KT3 .750 KT5 .714 -.261 KT6 .249 .530 .285 THCN7 .820 THCN2 .766 -.321 THCN1 .745 -.642 THCN3 .223 .567 -.210 THCN8 .550 NL2 .500 .234 NL3 .232 .468 NL4 .400 .352 PTHT3 .220 -.222 .592 PTHT2 .590 PTHT1 .544 PTHT5 .267 .511 -.210 PTHT6 .463 GT4 .827 GT5 .761 GT3 .506 KNHT1 .556 KNHT2 .248 .209 .526 lx KNHT4 .255 .450 KNHT3 .334 KN3 .684 KN2 .227 .640 KN5 .409 .412 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 9 iterations. 6.11. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 11: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .916 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 11152.228 df 861 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 12.101 28.812 28.812 11.675 27.798 27.798 8.399 2 3.681 8.765 37.577 3.271 7.788 35.586 7.026 3 2.422 5.768 43.345 1.980 4.714 40.299 7.373 4 2.159 5.140 48.484 1.648 3.923 44.222 6.670 5 1.661 3.956 52.440 1.215 2.892 47.114 3.400 6 1.336 3.181 55.621 .927 2.208 49.322 5.208 7 1.279 3.046 58.667 .818 1.947 51.269 6.614 8 1.126 2.681 61.348 .638 1.518 52.787 1.910 9 1.005 2.394 63.742 .571 1.361 54.147 1.676 10 .930 2.213 65.955 11 .873 2.080 68.034 12 .839 1.998 70.032 13 .796 1.895 71.928 14 .745 1.775 73.702 15 .707 1.684 75.386 16 .681 1.622 77.008 17 .636 1.514 78.523 18 .595 1.417 79.940 19 .569 1.355 81.295 20 .537 1.278 82.573 lxi 21 .506 1.205 83.779 22 .493 1.173 84.952 23 .477 1.136 86.088 24 .465 1.108 87.196 25 .436 1.037 88.233 26 .429 1.021 89.254 27 .400 .952 90.206 28 .373 .888 91.093 29 .363 .865 91.959 30 .348 .829 92.787 31 .340 .809 93.596 32 .323 .769 94.365 33 .317 .755 95.120 34 .304 .723 95.843 35 .284 .677 96.520 36 .264 .629 97.149 37 .248 .591 97.739 38 .237 .563 98.303 39 .214 .510 98.813 40 .205 .489 99.302 41 .156 .372 99.674 42 .137 .326 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 KN11 .851 KN10 .844 -.262 KN7 .729 KN9 .725 -.218 KN8 .673 KN6 .537 .229 THCN5 .398 TĐ4 .866 TĐ5 .807 TĐ6 .706 TĐ3 .706 TĐ2 .562 TĐ1 .524 KT2 .871 .219 KT4 .762 lxii KT3 .760 KT1 .758 KT5 .734 -.253 KT6 .274 .565 - .220 THCN7 .746 THCN8 .577 NL2 .575 .205 NL4 .551 .322 NL3 .232 .516 THCN2 .513 .362 THCN3 .209 .407 .224 PTHT3 .201 .584 PTHT2 .567 PTHT1 .530 PTHT5 .254 .498 -.213 PTHT6 .438 GT4 .843 GT5 .763 GT3 .498 KNHT1 .592 KNHT2 .229 .277 .523 KNHT4 .240 .487 KNHT5 .413 .422 KNHT3 .373 KN3 .686 KN2 .224 .632 THCN1 .264 .763 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 9 iterations. 6.12. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 12: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .915 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 10875.290 df 820 Sig. 0.000 lxiii Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 11.825 28.841 28.841 11.406 27.818 27.818 7.962 2 3.639 8.876 37.717 3.229 7.875 35.693 6.872 3 2.421 5.904 43.622 1.978 4.823 40.517 7.256 4 2.139 5.218 48.839 1.632 3.979 44.496 6.603 5 1.661 4.051 52.890 1.219 2.973 47.469 3.437 6 1.336 3.257 56.147 .932 2.274 49.743 5.291 7 1.273 3.105 59.252 .810 1.975 51.718 6.753 8 1.108 2.703 61.955 .639 1.560 53.277 1.786 9 1.004 2.449 64.404 .570 1.390 54.667 1.704 10 .888 2.166 66.570 11 .857 2.090 68.660 12 .805 1.963 70.623 13 .750 1.828 72.451 14 .730 1.781 74.231 15 .687 1.675 75.906 16 .671 1.636 77.542 17 .624 1.521 79.063 18 .588 1.435 80.498 19 .544 1.328 81.826 20 .513 1.251 83.077 21 .505 1.231 84.308 22 .489 1.193 85.501 23 .477 1.164 86.665 24 .463 1.130 87.795 25 .430 1.049 88.843 26 .422 1.029 89.872 27 .377 .920 90.792 28 .369 .901 91.693 29 .352 .858 92.551 30 .341 .831 93.383 31 .333 .812 94.194 32 .317 .774 94.968 33 .307 .750 95.718 34 .287 .699 96.417 35 .265 .646 97.063 36 .249 .607 97.670 37 .237 .579 98.249 lxiv 38 .219 .534 98.783 39 .206 .502 99.285 40 .156 .381 99.666 41 .137 .334 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 KN10 .866 -.233 KN11 .816 KN9 .736 KN7 .705 KN8 .642 KN6 .512 .247 TĐ4 .870 TĐ5 .808 TĐ3 .707 TĐ6 .697 TĐ2 .562 TĐ1 .520 .201 KT2 .873 .206 KT1 .764 KT4 .759 KT3 .747 KT5 .738 -.261 KT6 .268 .575 -.223 THCN7 .775 NL2 .592 .204 THCN8 .590 NL4 .548 .328 NL3 .214 .524 THCN2 .504 .361 THCN3 .417 .225 PTHT3 .575 PTHT2 .572 PTHT1 .536 PTHT5 .232 .500 -.201 PTHT6 .442 GT4 .844 GT5 .778 GT3 .511 lxv KNHT1 .639 KNHT2 .213 .278 .522 KNHT4 .238 .490 KNHT5 .397 .429 KNHT3 .359 KN3 .720 KN2 .232 .588 THCN1 .241 .768 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 9 iterations. 6.13. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 13: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .914 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 10646.428 df 780 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 11.625 29.063 29.063 11.196 27.989 27.989 7.799 2 3.638 9.096 38.159 3.214 8.035 36.024 7.033 3 2.361 5.903 44.062 1.915 4.787 40.810 7.265 4 2.132 5.330 49.392 1.613 4.032 44.842 5.778 5 1.598 3.995 53.387 1.103 2.758 47.601 3.393 6 1.325 3.313 56.700 .918 2.296 49.897 5.243 7 1.270 3.175 59.875 .768 1.921 51.817 6.592 8 1.105 2.762 62.637 .618 1.545 53.362 2.234 9 .978 2.446 65.083 10 .883 2.208 67.291 11 .817 2.043 69.334 12 .785 1.963 71.297 13 .732 1.829 73.126 14 .701 1.752 74.878 15 .680 1.699 76.577 16 .640 1.601 78.178 lxvi 17 .609 1.522 79.700 18 .554 1.384 81.084 19 .541 1.352 82.436 20 .508 1.271 83.707 21 .499 1.249 84.956 22 .488 1.221 86.176 23 .476 1.190 87.367 24 .433 1.083 88.450 25 .428 1.069 89.519 26 .384 .959 90.478 27 .377 .943 91.421 28 .361 .902 92.323 29 .341 .852 93.175 30 .337 .841 94.017 31 .318 .794 94.810 32 .310 .775 95.585 33 .287 .717 96.302 34 .271 .677 96.979 35 .250 .625 97.603 36 .239 .598 98.201 37 .219 .548 98.749 38 .206 .516 99.265 39 .156 .391 99.656 40 .138 .344 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 KN10 .869 -.205 KN11 .821 KN9 .736 KN7 .691 KN8 .647 KN6 .488 KNHT5 .420 .415 TĐ4 .894 TĐ5 .837 TĐ6 .723 TĐ3 .714 TĐ2 .573 TĐ1 .545 lxvii KT2 .863 KT1 .776 KT4 .761 KT3 .751 KT5 .748 -.216 KT6 .231 .591 THCN7 .733 THCN2 .664 THCN1 .660 -.230 THCN3 .532 THCN8 .471 NL2 .390 .246 .247 NL3 .208 .360 .268 PTHT2 .599 PTHT3 .222 -.206 .571 PTHT1 .516 PTHT5 .241 .498 PTHT6 .465 GT4 .802 GT5 .799 GT3 .507 KNHT2 .235 .612 NL4 .243 .604 KNHT1 .504 KNHT4 .285 .383 KN3 .674 KN2 .222 .623 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.14. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 14: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .909 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 10175.744 df 741 Sig. 0.000 lxviii Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 11.119 28.511 28.511 10.688 27.404 27.404 6.900 2 3.617 9.276 37.786 3.191 8.183 35.587 7.071 3 2.361 6.054 43.840 1.913 4.904 40.491 7.239 4 2.097 5.376 49.217 1.580 4.053 44.544 5.598 5 1.592 4.081 53.298 1.104 2.830 47.374 3.161 6 1.320 3.384 56.682 .918 2.353 49.727 5.237 7 1.250 3.205 59.887 .739 1.895 51.622 5.767 8 1.094 2.805 62.691 .613 1.573 53.195 2.434 9 .973 2.494 65.186 10 .882 2.262 67.448 11 .817 2.095 69.543 12 .785 2.014 71.557 13 .732 1.876 73.433 14 .700 1.794 75.227 15 .671 1.721 76.948 16 .621 1.592 78.540 17 .602 1.544 80.084 18 .552 1.416 81.500 19 .539 1.381 82.881 20 .506 1.297 84.179 21 .499 1.281 85.460 22 .481 1.232 86.692 23 .463 1.188 87.880 24 .429 1.100 88.980 25 .401 1.028 90.008 26 .383 .983 90.991 27 .375 .962 91.954 28 .360 .924 92.877 29 .337 .864 93.742 30 .319 .819 94.561 31 .310 .796 95.356 32 .305 .781 96.138 33 .279 .714 96.852 34 .258 .663 97.515 35 .244 .626 98.141 36 .219 .563 98.703 37 .207 .530 99.233 lxix 38 .157 .402 99.634 39 .143 .366 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 TĐ4 .895 TĐ5 .840 TĐ6 .730 TĐ3 .712 TĐ2 .583 TĐ1 .558 KT2 .872 KT1 .777 KT4 .767 KT3 .756 KT5 .738 KT6 .588 .225 KN10 .864 -.202 KN11 .833 .207 KN9 .720 KN7 .682 KN8 .646 KN6 .487 .214 THCN7 .708 THCN1 .694 -.238 THCN2 .677 THCN3 .534 THCN8 .439 NL2 .359 .242 .291 NL3 .213 .325 .316 PTHT2 .591 PTHT3 .226 .567 PTHT1 .506 PTHT5 .234 .500 PTHT6 .459 GT5 .810 GT4 .808 GT3 .512 NL4 .201 .641 KNHT2 .247 .574 lxx KNHT1 .224 .452 KNHT4 .310 .335 KN3 .690 KN2 .222 .626 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 8 iterations. 6.15. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 15: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .907 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 9779.124 df 703 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 10.920 28.736 28.736 10.490 27.606 27.606 6.892 2 3.313 8.718 37.454 2.882 7.583 35.189 7.149 3 2.342 6.162 43.617 1.898 4.995 40.184 6.933 4 2.092 5.506 49.123 1.565 4.118 44.302 5.261 5 1.591 4.188 53.311 1.104 2.906 47.208 2.984 6 1.300 3.421 56.732 .899 2.365 49.573 5.426 7 1.250 3.289 60.021 .738 1.942 51.515 5.571 8 1.093 2.877 62.898 .616 1.621 53.135 2.188 9 .972 2.557 65.455 10 .882 2.322 67.777 11 .817 2.149 69.926 12 .779 2.051 71.977 13 .703 1.849 73.826 14 .674 1.774 75.600 15 .651 1.714 77.314 16 .617 1.623 78.936 17 .593 1.561 80.498 18 .551 1.450 81.947 19 .535 1.407 83.354 20 .505 1.330 84.684 21 .490 1.290 85.973 lxxi 22 .480 1.263 87.236 23 .455 1.197 88.433 24 .421 1.109 89.542 25 .400 1.054 90.595 26 .383 1.008 91.603 27 .363 .954 92.558 28 .341 .897 93.455 29 .334 .880 94.335 30 .319 .840 95.175 31 .310 .815 95.990 32 .282 .742 96.732 33 .264 .696 97.428 34 .245 .645 98.074 35 .226 .594 98.667 36 .207 .544 99.212 37 .157 .413 99.625 38 .143 .375 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 TĐ4 .893 TĐ5 .839 TĐ6 .731 TĐ3 .712 TĐ2 .580 TĐ1 .556 KT2 .871 KT1 .774 KT4 .770 KT3 .761 KT5 .742 KT6 .592 .222 KN10 .850 KN11 .823 .217 KN9 .712 KN7 .677 KN8 .641 KN6 .487 .220 THCN7 .706 THCN2 .672 lxxii THCN1 .670 -.220 THCN3 .527 THCN8 .444 NL2 .349 .253 .270 PTHT2 .591 PTHT3 .224 .549 PTHT1 .514 PTHT5 .242 .498 -.210 PTHT6 .461 GT5 .819 GT4 .807 GT3 .516 NL4 .211 .608 KNHT2 .246 .598 KNHT1 .217 .469 KNHT4 .305 .344 KN3 .693 KN2 .227 .607 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.16. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 16: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .905 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 9503.031 df 666 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 10.688 28.887 28.887 10.263 27.739 27.739 6.735 2 3.248 8.779 37.667 2.820 7.623 35.361 7.098 3 2.324 6.281 43.947 1.891 5.110 40.472 6.824 4 2.029 5.484 49.432 1.481 4.004 44.475 4.860 5 1.583 4.278 53.709 1.104 2.984 47.460 2.683 6 1.267 3.425 57.134 .862 2.330 49.790 5.395 lxxiii 7 1.249 3.375 60.510 .735 1.987 51.777 5.351 8 1.093 2.955 63.464 .618 1.669 53.446 2.116 9 .952 2.572 66.036 10 .873 2.360 68.396 11 .814 2.201 70.597 12 .721 1.949 72.546 13 .703 1.899 74.444 14 .673 1.819 76.263 15 .644 1.742 78.005 16 .594 1.607 79.612 17 .564 1.525 81.136 18 .550 1.486 82.622 19 .524 1.416 84.038 20 .505 1.364 85.402 21 .480 1.297 86.699 22 .469 1.268 87.967 23 .424 1.145 89.112 24 .407 1.100 90.212 25 .386 1.043 91.255 26 .377 1.018 92.273 27 .350 .947 93.220 28 .334 .904 94.124 29 .322 .871 94.995 30 .315 .851 95.846 31 .284 .768 96.615 32 .270 .729 97.343 33 .248 .670 98.013 34 .228 .617 98.630 35 .207 .559 99.189 36 .158 .426 99.615 37 .143 .385 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 TĐ4 .887 TĐ5 .834 TĐ6 .729 TĐ3 .705 TĐ2 .574 TĐ1 .557 lxxiv KT2 .871 KT1 .775 KT4 .774 KT3 .759 KT5 .744 KT6 .593 .228 KN10 .856 KN11 .807 .224 KN9 .746 KN7 .681 KN8 .634 KN6 .487 .220 THCN2 .693 THCN1 .678 THCN7 .661 THCN3 .524 THCN8 .424 PTHT2 .581 PTHT3 .231 .545 PTHT5 .220 .510 -.228 PTHT1 .503 PTHT6 .464 GT5 .811 GT4 .808 GT3 .524 KNHT2 .237 .604 NL4 .201 .205 .576 KNHT1 .223 .493 KNHT4 .310 .360 KN3 .684 KN2 .222 .614 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.17. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 17: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .901 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 9212.895 df 630 Sig. 0.000 lxxv Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 10.312 28.644 28.644 9.892 27.477 27.477 6.880 2 3.244 9.010 37.654 2.818 7.827 35.304 6.401 3 2.310 6.417 44.071 1.873 5.203 40.508 6.688 4 2.022 5.617 49.688 1.477 4.103 44.611 4.804 5 1.583 4.396 54.084 1.107 3.075 47.686 2.612 6 1.251 3.475 57.559 .845 2.347 50.033 5.291 7 1.227 3.409 60.968 .719 1.998 52.030 2.197 8 1.077 2.993 63.961 .610 1.693 53.724 4.389 9 .948 2.632 66.593 10 .873 2.425 69.018 11 .802 2.227 71.245 12 .721 2.003 73.249 13 .683 1.898 75.146 14 .669 1.859 77.005 15 .644 1.789 78.794 16 .586 1.627 80.421 17 .553 1.537 81.958 18 .528 1.468 83.425 19 .506 1.407 84.832 20 .480 1.334 86.166 21 .469 1.304 87.471 22 .433 1.203 88.674 23 .421 1.168 89.842 24 .395 1.098 90.940 25 .377 1.047 91.987 26 .353 .979 92.966 27 .342 .950 93.915 28 .331 .920 94.836 29 .315 .875 95.711 30 .285 .793 96.504 31 .270 .751 97.254 32 .251 .697 97.951 33 .228 .634 98.585 34 .207 .575 99.160 35 .160 .444 99.604 36 .143 .396 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. lxxvi Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 KT2 .874 KT1 .777 KT4 .772 KT3 .760 KT5 .736 KT6 .582 .222 TĐ4 .880 TĐ5 .823 TĐ6 .726 TĐ3 .704 TĐ2 .576 TĐ1 .566 KN10 .861 -.205 KN11 .820 .218 KN9 .743 KN7 .686 KN8 .647 KN6 .495 .236 THCN1 .696 -.208 THCN2 .694 THCN7 .652 THCN3 .513 THCN8 .416 PTHT2 .579 PTHT3 .230 .546 PTHT5 .215 .511 -.232 PTHT1 .503 PTHT6 .463 GT4 .813 GT5 .812 GT3 .526 KN3 .698 KN2 .220 .612 NL4 .205 .564 KNHT2 .272 .557 KNHT1 .246 .439 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. lxxvii 6.18. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 18: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .898 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 8885.065 df 595 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 9.987 28.534 28.534 9.571 27.346 27.346 6.895 2 3.239 9.255 37.789 2.818 8.052 35.398 6.653 3 2.298 6.566 44.355 1.857 5.305 40.703 6.371 4 1.994 5.698 50.053 1.455 4.157 44.860 5.374 5 1.571 4.489 54.542 1.125 3.214 48.074 3.013 6 1.249 3.569 58.111 .833 2.381 50.454 5.096 7 1.199 3.427 61.538 .735 2.100 52.554 1.893 8 1.030 2.944 64.482 .589 1.682 54.236 1.358 9 .895 2.556 67.038 10 .840 2.400 69.438 11 .780 2.228 71.666 12 .708 2.023 73.689 13 .682 1.948 75.638 14 .664 1.897 77.535 15 .618 1.766 79.301 16 .582 1.661 80.962 17 .553 1.579 82.541 18 .528 1.509 84.051 19 .491 1.404 85.454 20 .480 1.371 86.826 21 .460 1.316 88.141 22 .431 1.233 89.374 23 .404 1.155 90.529 24 .392 1.119 91.648 25 .355 1.014 92.662 26 .344 .984 93.646 27 .334 .955 94.601 28 .330 .942 95.543 29 .287 .819 96.362 lxxviii 30 .278 .793 97.155 31 .256 .731 97.885 32 .228 .652 98.538 33 .209 .596 99.133 34 .160 .457 99.590 35 .144 .410 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 KN11 .909 KN10 .856 -.228 KN9 .742 -.227 KN7 .739 KN8 .721 KN6 .572 KNHT2 .418 .275 KT2 .900 KT4 .790 KT1 .779 KT3 .769 KT5 .678 KT6 .241 .541 TĐ4 .890 TĐ5 .827 TĐ6 .737 TĐ3 .706 TĐ2 .595 TĐ1 .204 .588 THCN1 .816 -.586 THCN2 .757 THCN7 .697 THCN3 .536 THCN8 .460 PTHT2 .579 PTHT3 .216 .574 PTHT1 .530 PTHT5 .522 -.224 PTHT6 .466 GT4 .831 GT5 .808 lxxix GT3 .219 .510 KN3 .704 KN2 .233 .609 NL4 .206 .301 .356 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.19. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 19: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .897 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 8571.665 df 561 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 9.754 28.689 28.689 9.323 27.421 27.421 6.656 2 3.122 9.181 37.870 2.681 7.886 35.307 6.573 3 2.296 6.752 44.622 1.854 5.453 40.760 6.205 4 1.981 5.826 50.449 1.423 4.185 44.945 4.908 5 1.567 4.610 55.059 1.079 3.174 48.118 2.776 6 1.249 3.673 58.732 .790 2.324 50.442 4.933 7 1.126 3.313 62.045 .641 1.886 52.328 2.128 8 .963 2.832 64.877 9 .891 2.619 67.497 10 .815 2.396 69.893 11 .777 2.286 72.179 12 .708 2.082 74.261 13 .664 1.953 76.214 14 .662 1.948 78.162 15 .609 1.791 79.953 16 .581 1.709 81.662 17 .552 1.622 83.285 18 .496 1.459 84.743 19 .491 1.444 86.188 20 .462 1.360 87.547 21 .432 1.270 88.817 lxxx 22 .425 1.250 90.067 23 .396 1.165 91.232 24 .381 1.122 92.354 25 .355 1.043 93.397 26 .335 .984 94.381 27 .332 .976 95.356 28 .291 .856 96.213 29 .280 .823 97.035 30 .257 .757 97.792 31 .228 .671 98.464 32 .215 .632 99.095 33 .162 .476 99.571 34 .146 .429 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 KT2 .893 KT1 .801 KT3 .763 KT4 .763 KT5 .664 KT6 .591 .252 KN11 .924 KN10 .773 KN7 .751 KN8 .724 KN9 .678 KN6 .593 KNHT2 .460 TĐ4 .888 TĐ5 .820 TĐ6 .730 TĐ3 .707 TĐ2 .588 TĐ1 .222 .580 THCN2 .742 THCN7 .673 THCN1 .637 THCN3 .538 THCN8 .216 .443 lxxxi PTHT2 .589 PTHT3 .229 .558 PTHT1 .531 PTHT5 .502 PTHT6 .467 GT5 .821 GT4 .798 GT3 .210 .488 KN2 .697 KN3 .624 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.20. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 20: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .892 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 8226.512 df 528 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 9.396 28.473 28.473 8.971 27.185 27.185 6.489 2 3.035 9.198 37.670 2.591 7.853 35.037 6.042 3 2.293 6.949 44.620 1.853 5.616 40.653 6.020 4 1.970 5.971 50.591 1.418 4.296 44.949 4.614 5 1.566 4.744 55.335 1.078 3.265 48.214 2.685 6 1.247 3.780 59.115 .788 2.388 50.601 4.958 7 1.126 3.413 62.527 .649 1.965 52.567 2.010 8 .944 2.860 65.387 9 .884 2.679 68.066 10 .789 2.392 70.458 11 .725 2.196 72.654 12 .704 2.133 74.787 13 .664 2.011 76.798 14 .622 1.883 78.682 15 .605 1.833 80.515 lxxxii 16 .577 1.750 82.265 17 .551 1.668 83.933 18 .493 1.493 85.426 19 .490 1.484 86.910 20 .462 1.399 88.308 21 .432 1.308 89.616 22 .408 1.236 90.852 23 .385 1.166 92.018 24 .355 1.075 93.093 25 .339 1.028 94.121 26 .332 1.005 95.126 27 .317 .961 96.088 28 .282 .853 96.941 29 .258 .781 97.722 30 .229 .693 98.415 31 .215 .651 99.066 32 .162 .492 99.558 33 .146 .442 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 KT2 .890 KT1 .798 KT3 .762 KT4 .761 KT5 .667 KT6 .592 .247 TĐ4 .887 TĐ5 .819 TĐ6 .727 TĐ3 .705 TĐ2 .583 TĐ1 .223 .577 KN11 .897 KN10 .768 KN7 .739 KN8 .709 KN9 .670 KN6 .564 THCN2 .731 lxxxiii THCN7 .663 THCN1 .656 THCN3 .538 THCN8 .208 .444 PTHT2 .587 PTHT3 .231 .553 PTHT1 .534 PTHT5 .503 -.207 PTHT6 .464 GT5 .821 GT4 .807 GT3 .208 .498 KN2 .737 KN3 .582 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. 6.21. Kết quả kiểm định lần thứ 21: KMO and Bartlett's Test Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy. .886 Bartlett's Test of Sphericity Approx. Chi-Square 7865.160 df 496 Sig. 0.000 Total Variance Explained Factor Initial Eigenvalues Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings Rotation Sums of Squared Loadings a Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total % of Variance Cumulative % Total 1 9.003 28.134 28.134 8.579 26.810 26.810 6.201 2 2.989 9.342 37.476 2.549 7.966 34.776 5.708 3 2.291 7.161 44.637 1.853 5.792 40.568 5.857 4 1.970 6.155 50.792 1.415 4.423 44.990 4.537 5 1.544 4.826 55.618 1.048 3.275 48.265 2.639 6 1.221 3.816 59.434 .742 2.318 50.583 4.141 7 1.066 3.332 62.765 .650 2.032 52.615 2.072 8 .928 2.900 65.666 9 .879 2.748 68.414 10 .788 2.462 70.875 lxxxiv 11 .724 2.263 73.138 12 .701 2.190 75.329 13 .658 2.055 77.384 14 .616 1.925 79.309 15 .585 1.829 81.138 16 .575 1.797 82.934 17 .549 1.716 84.650 18 .490 1.530 86.180 19 .479 1.497 87.678 20 .442 1.380 89.058 21 .420 1.313 90.371 22 .407 1.272 91.643 23 .379 1.186 92.829 24 .345 1.077 93.906 25 .332 1.037 94.943 26 .318 .994 95.937 27 .282 .880 96.817 28 .266 .830 97.647 29 .229 .715 98.362 30 .216 .675 99.036 31 .162 .508 99.544 32 .146 .456 100.000 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. a. When factors are correlated, sums of squared loadings cannot be added to obtain a total variance. Pattern Matrixa Factor 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 KT2 .889 KT1 .798 KT3 .764 KT4 .756 KT5 .659 KT6 .590 .246 TĐ4 .881 TĐ5 .815 TĐ6 .724 TĐ3 .705 TĐ2 .581 TĐ1 .226 .574 KN11 .887 KN10 .778 lxxxv KN7 .735 KN8 .702 KN9 .678 KN6 .558 THCN2 .732 THCN7 .667 THCN1 .652 THCN3 .535 THCN8 .202 .447 PTHT2 .590 PTHT3 .230 .551 PTHT1 .537 PTHT5 .496 PTHT6 .461 GT4 .800 GT5 .786 KN2 .759 KN3 .574 Extraction Method: Principal Axis Factoring. Rotation Method: Promax with Kaiser Normalization. a a. Rotation converged in 7 iterations. Bảng 6.1: Ma trận mẫu Pattern Matrix a Factor 1 2 3 4 5 KT2 .887 KT1 .805 KT3 .795 KT4 .788 KT5 .662 KT6 .573 TĐ4 .872 TĐ5 .809 TĐ3 .736 TĐ6 .727 lxxxvi TĐ2 .619 TĐ1 .564 KN11 .871 KN10 .757 KN7 .745 KN8 .711 KN9 .661 KN6 .548 THCN2 .768 THCN1 .669 THCN7 .568 THCN3 .533 PTHT1 .687 PTHT2 .613 lxxxvii Phụ lục 7: KẾT QUẢ PHÂN TÍCH NHÂN TỐ KHẲNG ĐỊNH (CFA) Hình 7.1: Mô hình phân tích nhân tố khẳng định (CFA) lxxxviii Phụ lục 8: MÔ HÌNH CẤU TRÚC (SEM) Hình 8.1: Mô hình cấu trúc (SEM) lxxxix Bảng 8.1: Trọng số hồi quy Regression Weights: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label THCN <--- KT .173 .061 2.809 .005 THCN <--- TĐ .044 .068 .653 .513 THCN <--- KN .406 .051 7.945 *** THCN <--- PTHT .157 .052 3.008 .003 KT2 <--- KT 1.000 KT1 <--- KT .880 .033 27.054 *** KT3 <--- KT 1.104 .052 21.224 *** KT4 <--- KT 1.057 .053 19.811 *** KT5 <--- KT 1.008 .064 15.805 *** KT6 <--- KT .815 .058 13.955 *** TĐ4 <--- TĐ 1.000 TĐ5 <--- TĐ .954 .043 21.934 *** TĐ3 <--- TĐ .925 .058 15.959 *** TĐ6 <--- TĐ .965 .055 17.463 *** TĐ2 <--- TĐ .809 .058 13.975 *** TĐ1 <--- TĐ .874 .054 16.104 *** xc Estimate S.E. C.R. P Label KN11 <--- KN 1.000 KN10 <--- KN .670 .042 15.935 *** KN7 <--- KN .811 .049 16.583 *** KN8 <--- KN .864 .046 18.792 *** KN9 <--- KN .559 .039 14.496 *** KN6 <--- KN .783 .052 15.070 *** THCN2 <--- THCN 1.000 THCN1 <--- THCN 1.020 .087 11.696 *** THCN7 <--- THCN .857 .086 10.014 *** THCN3 <--- THCN .866 .071 12.196 *** PTHT1 <--- PTHT 1.000 PTHT2 <--- PTHT 2.468 1.194 2.067 .039 Bảng 8.2: Trọng số hồi quy chuẩn Standardized Regression Weights: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate KT2 <--- KT 0.824 KT1 <--- KT 0.749 KT3 <--- KT 0.845 KT4 <--- KT 0.798 xci KT5 <--- KT 0.669 KT6 <--- KT 0.604 TĐ4 <--- TĐ 0.809 TĐ5 <--- TĐ 0.733 TĐ3 <--- TĐ 0.701 TĐ6 <--- TĐ 0.760 TĐ2 <--- TĐ 0.624 TĐ1 <--- TĐ 0.707 KN11 <--- KN 0.821 KN10 <--- KN 0.685 KN7 <--- KN 0.706 KN8 <--- KN 0.783 KN9 <--- KN 0.634 KN6 <--- KN 0.652 THCN2 <--- THCN 0.647 THCN1 <--- THCN 0.679 THCN7 <--- THCN 0.551 THCN3 <--- THCN 0.731 PTHT1 <--- PTHT 0.579 PTHT2 <--- PTHT 1.149 Bảng 8.3: Tương quan Correlations: (Group number 1 - Default model) Estimate KN THCN 0.612 KN PTHT 0.145 KT TĐ 0.527 KT KN 0.445 xcii KT THCN 0.437 KT PTHT 0.169 TĐ KN 0.387 TĐ THCN 0.336 TĐ PTHT 0.101 THCN PTHT 0.227

Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:

  • pdfluan_an_nghien_cuu_thuong_hieu_to_chuc_va_thuong_hieu_ca_nha.pdf
Luận văn liên quan